Post # 31
Definitely wait, but make it clear that you are always going to be there for her. Talk in a way that makes it clear that your future will be spent together, you could even say “after we’re married…” This way she has the comfort of knowing you are there going through this with her and not just that you happen to be the guy she’s with during this tragedy.
After going through such a hard experience she (and you too!) deserve to have the engagement be a good, happy thing. I voted wait at least a month, but I think 6 months is better. Grief is a slow process and the hardest parts are probably stilll to come. Life has to go on, and it will, so give her time.
Post # 32
Depending on how she and her family are doing, I do like the idea of a new years proposal in this case. I love what PP said about her new years proposal after a terrible year. It’s a very nice way to look at it.
If you aim for that, that would also give you the chance to talk with her parents about it over the holidays and get their thoughts on it. If they say it’s too soon, respect that and ask them when they think it would be appropriate.
And in the meantime, I agree with PP about talking to your girlfriend using phrasing that is clear about your intent to marry her. Talk about in twenty years when we… at our wedding… When we get married… Etc. The comfort of knowing you absolutely view her as your life partner is a good thing. But let her grieve properly before expecting her to celebrate engagement and start planning a wedding. It’s just too much.
Post # 33
This is so tragic im so sorry for your girlfriend losing her sister. I think a thanksgiving /Holiday proposal would be a better idea , Give her a little more than a month she may not be in the right state of mind. She might reject your proposal if you do it now because she is still processing losing her sister. Again so sorry and please let us know what you are going to do!!!
Post # 34
Wait until New Years at the very earliest. I don’t think a lot of the pps suggesting a holiday proposal understand how truly horrible this holiday season will be for your gfs family. I lost my grandmother, after a very long full life, over the summer. I couldn’t even bare facing Thanksgiving and the subsequent holidays without her. In fact, my family didn’t celebrate that year. If my SO tried to propose during that time, I’m positive I would have ended the relationship. And because Thanksgiving was my grandmothers holiday to host, I couldn’t bare to celebrate it for many years, until I started celebrating with my now husbands family. The grief of losing someone so close to the holiday season is hard enough, but it is a truly devastating tragedy how young and sudden the death was.
Post # 35
That’s a terrible idea to suggest a Thanksgiving/Holiday proposal. The first holidays following the loss of a loved one are awful, especially a tragic loss of someone so young.
OP, you need to wait on this. It’s really too bad that you did not do this in the previous 6 months. But, there is no way you should this now or anytime in the near future. Her girlfriend needs time to grieve, time to process, and time to heal.
Post # 36
Ok so I went through this, I lost my sister at 31 years old in January of 2019s It was sudden shocking and the worst grief of my life.
Imo, you should wait at least a few months before proposing. Let her grieve. Let her family grieve. It will be a happy time for her when she is engaged but don’t be surprised if it bring up a lot of sadness as well since the loss of her sister can become more apparently and gaping during happy times when she won’t be there to celebrate with you both: be gentle and kind. She is hurting a lot and she just needs to be able to grieve right now. If I were you it might be good to wait until the new year.
Post # 37
Do not listen to anyone who says to do it around the holidays. This year will be slow torture during Christmas and thanksgiving without my sister. Heck my bday is in a week and I’m already so distraught she’s not going to celebrate it with me.
Wait until AT LEAST January.
Post # 38
I complely agree with you and know how you feel :(. Happy times are always going to have a dark cloud surrounding them without her. LilliV :
Post # 39
One of my good friends died at 29, and then my Fiance proposed to me (similar thinking as you). While I was happy I was also grieving. I would wait until your girlfriend is more herself… at least several months.
Post # 40
I can’t believe you are actually considering proposing at this time! The funeral and the first lot of family holidays need to come and go before you can even think about it. If someone proposed to me 2 days before my sister funeral I would tell them to take a hike.
Post # 41
Wait and wait for an indefinite time. I hate saying that, but if my sister died and so unexpectedly like that, I’m not sure I would want my boyfriend to propose for at least a year or two. And this is from someone who is currently waiting for him to propose. I would be struggling with wanting to stay alive myself if I lost her. Obviously everyone is different and I do understand the want to make it official when you are reminded of how short life is…but this is a really big loss for her and it will take awhile for her to process it.