Post # 1
Would you like this bag and and something else TBD (available in a lot of different colors/styles)… Size 21″ x 12″ x 11″
Or a jewelry roll and only a jewelry roll (it’s more expensive than the bag)
Post # 3
i have tons of bags, and that size isn’t very practical for me. i think that size is a pain to stuff in on an airplane. i don’t have a jewelry roll, and that one is really cute!
Post # 4
I’ll take the jewelry roll, please. Do you need my address for shipping purposes? 😛
Post # 5
Okay I loved the bag in the other post, but that jewelry roll is so cute!
Post # 7
I wouldn’t use a jewelry roll and I have too many bags. I would prefer a personalized gift based on something that I like. Sorry not super helpful.
Edit: If the something else was personal, I would choose the bag option.
Post # 8
I said who cares…cause you won’t please everyone. But, I do like the bag more 🙂
Post # 9
Wait….let me guess – you loved the bag in the other post but this jewelry roll is so cute? LOL
Post # 10
Where did you find the jewelry roll? Its so cute! I like the bag but I already have a weekend bag so id prefer the jewelry roll if I was your bm.
Post # 11
I personally would LOVE either one! I don’t have a jewelry roll, nor had I heard of/seen 1 before your post, haha, but I feel like I’d get more use out the bag. But, it also depends on your girls. I’d love it for when I make a weekend trip home or to visit friends or something, since I don’t really have any small bags like that, but I know a couple of my girls already have super cute Vera Bradley weekender bags, so I nixed the idea of getting a bag like that for all of them.
Mind if I ask where you found the bag/how much it is? I think I am going to do a different gift for each girl, which I’m excited about, and 1 of my girls, my old college roommate, could totally use a weekender bag like that. She used to throw her clothes into plastic target bags & throw them into her car, & thats how she’d pack for a weekend trip home! haha. SO, I am thinking about getting her one for her gift, and I think the 1 you picked out is super cute!
Post # 12
I love both! Never can have too many bags!
Maybe you could find a cheaper jewelry roll and put their bridal jewelry in it, if wearing any!
Post # 13
I am so indecisive! All of my girls are so different and i know I’ll never please them all, I’ve just gotten SO MANY junky bridesmaids gifts in my life, that I am really trying to avoid that. I really don’t want the gift to be self-serving and then never be used again, which is why I am trying for something like this.
For those of you who are curious, both of these are from Etsy. The bag is from Stiched & Stamped and the jewelry roll is from Andrea Lynn Handmade.
I did find some cheaper jewelry rolls, but I really like how this one has a space to HANG necklaces and a place to HANG earrings and a roll for rings. I showed my Maid/Matron of Honor both of these and she loved them both, so she is of no use to me… 🙂
Post # 14
I like both! I know that won’t help you decide, but maybe it’ll take pressure off. If I was your Bridesmaid or Best Man I’d be happy with either.
Post # 15
Personally I would prefer the jewelry roll! What if you did a little digging and could find out what your girls would prefer? Or is that not right to do? I’m not sure, but both are practical and I’m sure they will be happy to get whatever one you pick! Although, the bag is something they could always find on their own, maybe the jewelry roll would be better because it wouldn’t necessarily be something they would find every day, if that makes any sense!
Post # 16
I like the jewellery roll better, but I could be biaed as I don’t have one & my taste in bags is different from what you’ve shown.