(Closed) "I'm Pregnant. So why can't I tell you?"

posted 4 years ago in TTC
Post # 2
2977 posts
Sugar bee

I shared right away they can be great support if you need it . 

Post # 3
1304 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2011

*Personally*, I felt that it would be easier for me to get over a miscarriage if I didn’t also have to tell a lot of people that I was no longer pregnant.  But I am an introvert and did not feel that other people would provide much useful support.

Post # 4
1533 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2013

Debating this currently.  I found out I’m pregnant a early last week (I’m 4w now) and I feel like the information has been burning a hole in my brain ever since.  I am really struggling with who to tell and when.  We definitely plan to tell close friends and family before 12 weeks, as I’d want to lean on them if something did happen.  But the how soon to share question is so hard right now.  I am vascillating between feeling protective of the information and reminding myself that “it’s so early”, and feeling like I’m going to explode if I don’t tell a few girlfriends very soon.  

Like the author of the articile, I am an oversharer by nature and terrible with secrets…. and it’s so weird that this crazy, thrilling, scary thing is now the biggest secret I’ve ever had.

Post # 5
2190 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: March 2013

Tess63110:  We told immediate family and friends right away! It took us over a year to conceive and they knew we were trying. We felt the same as you and wanted them to share in our joy and excitement. We wanted to celebrate the life we created, even if it was only to be short lived. If something bad were to happen we would want their support and understanding. Personally, I felt why should I go through that pain and suffering alone? I also would not have been able to hide any nausea and fatigue from them. I worked out a lot before getting pregnant and it significantly diminished in the first trimester due to not feeling well. Friends and family would certainly know something was up. 

We waited to do any social media about the pregnancy until we saw the baby’s heart beat at 7w5d. Luckily, I am now in the 2nd trimester and everything is going perfectly! Good luck to you!!

Post # 6
2837 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: November 2013

Tess63110:  I have never understood why people think it’s a big deal to keep pregnancy a secret for the first trimester- or beyond in some cases.

The only reason I didn’t tell anyone I was pregnant with my first- is because I wasn’t married at the time, and I wasn’t sure it was going to be recieved well- it had nothing to do with first trimester- more just be getting the courage to tell my family.

The baby- I don’t remember when we said anything…..maybe about 6-8 weeks?  I would have been about 5 or 5.5 weeks when I found out….and we didn’t hide it.

Even if something happens in the first trimester- you were still pregnant- no matter which way anyone tries to look at it….so why shouldn’t it be shared?

And then of course- if something does happen, you’ll have a larger support group than if you kept it to yourself.

I have a friend who is very Catholic and they have seven children.  She has had at least 2 miscarriages along the way.  I also know she hasn’t been shy about sharing each pregnancy- through social media- right from the start.  


Post # 7
4770 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: November 1999

MrsEME:  this.  It’s not shameful, it’s not embarassing.  Why is it that people are supposed to suffer through a misscarriage in secret?  

Once people actually open up about it they’d realize how common they are and I think it would be helpful in a theraputic way. 


But posting on fb, TNI!!

Post # 8
2638 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: July 2012

To each her own. One way might be right for some, and one might be best for another. It’s up to the couple and what they are comfortable with.

Post # 9
2837 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: November 2013

MrsEME:  I can’t edit my post- but when I said “The baby”- I meant to say “This baby”- since I am pregnant right now.

Post # 10
8786 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
  • Wedding: August 2012

I’ve had a MC so I can say from experience that I was happy we did not tell anyone beforehand. Just my opinion. I would not find telling people about it therapeutic at all.

If/when I get pregnant again, I would not tell anyone but my parents until at least 12 weeks.

Post # 11
10734 posts
Sugar Beekeeper

If you want to tell your nearest and dearest, I don’t think anyone would debate this. It’s not just about wanting the privacy in the event something went wrong, though that traditional superstition was a big part of it for me, personally. 

But nine months is just a loooonnngggg time for your more casual friends and extended family to stay as excited as you.   I know someone who announced the day the test stick came out positive, complete with photos and weekly updates on FB.  Rude as the  comments are, and they are, I heard people saying things like “Wow it seems like she’s been pregnant forever” or ” Hasn’t she had that baby by now?!” 


Post # 12
60 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: August 2013

I don’t think my husband and I would be able to keep a secret like that for 3 months lol. It would be out so fast.

The new baby is a big deal for the mom and dad, and their family… who cares if someone on social media no longer feels excited for the couple because the pregnancy is realistically timed? I agree that the weekly updates and pee test photos and cutesy signage is kind of annoying, but they can unfollow if they want to have the whole play by play. 40 weeks is a long time, and that’s just part of it.

Post # 13
1048 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

I’m 10 weeks pregnant, and we let immediate family know shortly after we found out but we haven’t told friends yet. I can understand why people want to tell straight away, but Im definitely more comfortable waiting until after the 12 week scan. I’m pretty introverted, and if something were to happen, I would hate having to tell people about it. I know everyone would be lovely and sympathetic but I think I’d even find it hard to deal with that. 


We told DHs grandmother shortly after we found out, and that made me feel really anxious afterwards – she’s been quite depressed ever since her daughter (DHs mother) passed away a few years ago, and she’s so happy about becoming a great grandmother that I would feel terrible about having to tell her if I were to miscarry. 

Post # 14
3014 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: October 2011

Tess63110:  It’s such a personal decision. If you’re comfortable telling the world right away (and then possibly telling everyone you miscarried) that is fine. If you want to keep it private until after the first trimester (or longer) that is fine, too. There’s no right answer.

When I got pregnant I told my mom right away, then a couple close friends at around 8 weeks. Everyone else was later. I felt extrememly guarded and private about. If I had miscarried I would have wanted to tell select people on my own terms, not have to “re-announce” to everyone and deal with their sadness or awkwardness or whatever. 

Post # 15
2517 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

If it were me I would tell my family and close friends right away, but not announce it on facebook or social media.  If you don’t talk to the person in real life, you probably don’t need to rely on them for support.   

The topic ‘"I'm Pregnant. So why can't I tell you?"’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors