(Closed) Is my engagement ring too small? =S

posted 12 years ago in Rings
Post # 3
3928 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: March 2011

If you love it, that is all that matters. I would try not to worry about. What other people think shouldn’t matter.

Post # 4
719 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2011

What the HELL is wrong with that woman, WHO would say that??  Honestly, she’s just stupid.  There’s nothing wrong with a .91 carat diamond, I think most people are lucky to get a carat, and it’s quite normal to get below that.  It all depends on the quality of the diamond too, not just the size… wow I would have loved to come up with a smartass remark after a comment like that, I wish I could think fast, that was just rude.  Don’t feel down on your ring, everyone has different tastes and opinions, can’t please everyone.  Besides, personally, I would feel uncomfortable wearing something SO expensive on my finger!!

Post # 5
719 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2011

ps – Congratulations on the engagement!!

Post # 6
120 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: July 2011

If you really love something, wouldn’t you be proud of it? To say otherwise is kind of a paradox.

It makes me so sad to see so many brides come on WB asking if their ring is “good enough”. Do not ever let someone else make you inferior. It sounds like you loved your ring before your friend’s (rude) mom made a comment she had no place to make. Don’t try to convince yourself that you don’t like your ring just because someone else acted high and mighty about its size. It isn’t about her preferences, it is about yours.

My center stone is approx 1 carat (little less), and I know there are lots of people with bigger ones, but my FH designed it FOR me, which makes it special. We are young adults so it fit into our budget, and the ring itself suits me.

In wedding planning, you will find that there is **ALWAYS** someone who can afford more than you and have more lavish things than you. Do not be consumed by material wants or you will never be happy, because somebody else will ALWAYS be able to outdo you. Be thankful for what you have and be true to what makes YOU happy.

Post # 7
1015 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: June 2010

First of all, anyone who says that to you is rude, has no manners, and most likely enjoys putting people down.

Second, your ring sounds beautiful!  .91 is a substantial size.  There are many girls out there who are thrilled with a .5 ct. 

Third, IT DOESN’T MATTER WHAT ANYONE THINKS EXCEPT YOURSELF AND YOUR Fiance.  Don’t compare your ring to others. 

Congratulations on the engagement!

Post # 8
8943 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
  • Wedding: June 2009

Congrats on getting engaged.  That woman is incredibly rude.  I think that you and your Fiance should make a decision what you can afford (whether it is .5 or 20 carats) and make sure that you can really afford it.  Getting an engagement ring is about the feelings and the meaning of the ring itself, not how big it is.

Post # 9
2836 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: December 2010

No, your ring is not too small. That is really rude of that lady to say something like that. Congrats on your engagement and Welcome to weddingbee!

Post # 10
36 posts

That is horribly rude of that woman to say anything.

As many others have posted, .91 is actually not that small. My diamond is not much larger than yours and I love it because it was DH’s mother’s first ring. His parents are still happily married and I appreciate the sentiment of the ring. The size, cut, etc. don’t matter as much as that it came from a happy home.

The ring should be whatever you and your fiance like and can afford. 

Post # 11
1278 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: January 2013

Okay…the average is NOWHERE near 5 carats, not even in a place where large stone are popular, like LA or NYC.  5 carats is a monster of a stone!  Your ring is almost 1 carat and that is more than a lot of women, but really, who cares?!  Did you love it before your friend’s mom’s incredibly rude comment? Do you adore the love and commitment it symbolizes?  Then that’s what matters.  Rejoice, because I’m sure your ring is gorgeous and perfect for you two as a couple, and .91 carats is NOT at all small.

Post # 12
3340 posts
Sugar bee

I asked my DH if he was ever planning on “upgrading” his band or if he was planning on “upgrading” my wedding set.  He said HELL NO because the rings we have are special!  They’ve been through “Popping the question” and our engagement shoot, our wedding ceremony and a special blessing!  The rings we have are special to US and it doesn’t matter if anyone else thinks that they “should” be something else.  It’s not up to them to decide anyway!  It’s not about the size, it’s about the thought behind the ring and if it is special to you.

Also, what kind of cut stone do you have?  You mentioned that a lot of the carat weight is under the face of the stone, which is true for some cuts and can make them look smaller.  (Still doesn’t mean that old bat should have said ANYTHING besides “What a gorgeous ring!”)

Post # 14
5592 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: June 2010

Congratulations on your engagment.

That is incredibly rude.  My centre stone clocks in at .75 carats, and as two working professionals came in at 1/3 of the budget we had established before we went shopping.  It turned out I preferred a more intricate setting compared to a larger solitaire, and for me, an intricate setting AND a large stone was a lot going on for one small hand.

It’s completely a matter of taste, and it’s nobody else’s place to talk about whether your ring is “good enough”.

Post # 15
469 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2010

My ring is 0.6 carat and just the right size for my hand. Both of our mother’s have a third of a carat, so mine is a big step up.

Plus, size isn’t the only aspect of a good diamond. Remember the 4 C’s play just as big a part if not more.

Post # 16
1300 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2010

first, CONGRATS 🙂

second, that woman is a horrid person to say something like that to you – did SHE buy it? is he ask HER to marry your FH? no! so what business is it of hers!?

personally i would have told that heifer to stuff it.

no one should EVER make you feel bad about your ring. it does NOT matter what size it is. what matters is the man that you love wants to spend the rest of his life with you – and it shouldnt matter if he gave you a piece of string or a 10 carat canary diamond.

he gave it to you as a promise of a future life, and dont ever feel you have to apologize or upgrade that moment.

cherish your ring. i know many a women who have much smaller rings than yours, and they could care less. why? because its not about the rock on your finger but about your marriage.

seriously tell that old heifer to stuff it.

*stepping off soapbox* that makes me so angry that she did that. people can be so rude and just … UGH.

The topic ‘Is my engagement ring too small? =S’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors