(Closed) jamaica vs st lucia

posted 6 years ago in Honeymoons
  • poll: jamaica or st lucia for Honeymoon


    st lucia


  • Post # 2
    1629 posts
    Bumble bee

    Haven’t been to St. Lucia and I’m no expert on the Carribean but we very much enjoyed our trip to Jamaica several years ago — highly recommend The Caves. 

    Post # 3
    881 posts
    Busy bee

    I went to montego bay and st lucia. I actually stayed at a sandals in st Lucia with an ex. He was boring, but sandals was amazing. We did fishing and booked a volcano, mud bath, waterfall, snorkeling day trip. There’s hiking in st Lucia too. I was with a stick in the mud so I couldnt get him out.   But the resort had wake boarding/water skiing and paddle boards there too. 

    Post # 4
    454 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: June 2016

    I’ve been to 4 of the Sandals resorts in Jamaica (all on the same trip) and they were great – we were not there for a honeymoon, but it would be really awesome for one. There are three Sandals in the Montego Bay area, we stayed at one of those and there was a free shuttle that ran all day between all three of them – staying at one of the resorts gave you access to all the others so we hung out at a different resort or bounced between them each day depending on what we wanted to do (one was more of a “party” place and another was more inimate – one had better beach area than another, etc). I thought this was really fun and gave us a lot of different things to do – it also gave us more entertainment and food options since they varied by resort. All three of them were within 10 minutes of each other on the shuttle, so it was super convenient.

    One of the days we decided to do an off-site excursion to Negril and stopped by the Sandals there since we had free access to the amenities and could eat for free. It was super nice as well and really fun, it was bigger than the ones in Montego Bay and I thought the beach was nicer (not that it’s not nice in Montego Bay) – we had great food there and there are some cool excursions you could do nearby in Negril. The Negril Sandals is right next to Hedonism II (google it if you aren’t familiar) so there are a lot of nude beachers, we didn’t mind, but just a heads up for those who might. We were actually going to try out the nude beach area, but fiance’s brother and his girlfriend were with us and he (brother) seemed uncomfortable which was totally fine, haha :).

    I have two sets of friends who honeymooned at the St. Lucia Sandals and both had great things to say. I think you can’t go wrong with either trip!

    Post # 6
    178 posts
    Blushing bee

    My brother in law and sister in law stayed at the St. Lucia Sandals resort and had an amazing time. Their pictures were gorgeous! If cost is not a factor, would vote for St. Lucia as its a bit off the beaten path so I think it’s a little more unique. But like others have said, sounds like you can’t go wrong with any choice. I do believe Jamaica will be cheaper though. 

    Post # 7
    1201 posts
    Bumble bee
    • Wedding: June 2014

    View original reply
    Ele88:  We did St Lucia and it was amazing! We didn’t stay at Sandals, but we passed by La Toc on our way to Pigeon Island and the outer wall and landscaping looked nice haha. It seemed really big, which wasn’t what we were going for, but can be fun 🙂

    St Lucia is a beautiful island, the people are all really friendly, and I feel like it’s the perfect size because there’s a lot to do if you want but not so much that you feel like you’re missing out if you decide to relax on the beach all day.

    The topic ‘jamaica vs st lucia’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors