Lab Diamond vs Forever One moissanite

posted 5 months ago in Rings
Post # 16
1542 posts
Bumble bee

I have a mined diamond e-ring but I have a big mixture of moissanite, lab diamond and colored stones. I decided to try an Asscher lab diamond. I don’t know if that is the best stone to buy sight unseen, especially if you go lower than a G. I thought I might be okay with an H, so I could at least get to an 8mm. I was willing to pay for a higher carat or higher grade but they just couldn’t seem to get past either.

It looks mostly white in person but I can still see quite a bit of brown tint. I am also kind of bothered that the table is not faceted. I decided to put a precision cut 8 mm Kori Asscher moissanite back in the same setting. It outsparkles and looks whiter then the diamond. I missed the scintillation that you get with a diamond and it can’t be recreated in moissanite in the same way for every cut. There is a little give and take with each choice. The moissanite is beautifully cut with crisp facets all the way through the table. I wish I could get the cut of one and the scintillation of the other. I was willing to give it a try though. Next time I will probably save to work with a jeweler for a higher quality lab diamond. I would still like a larger emerald and another cut of something brilliant. 

Post # 19
453 posts
Helper bee

View original reply
@flower895:  Oh that’s so great! Some stones just need a good scrubbing with a toothbrush, you can’t be scared to get in there and really scrub it (like it’s a tiny potato,  haha!) . I’m glad it’s sparkling again for you! 

Post # 20
309 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: May 2012

There’s really no right answer, a lot of it is entirely dependent on personal preference. I think Moissanite has an interesting sparkle and rainbow effect, and I would love to wear some on a pendant or in earrings. But I personally wouldn’t choose one for my wedding band or engagement ring. I would much rather get a lab diamond, especially now that they are so widely available and the prices have come down. But really that’s just me and my preference. Again, there is no right answer.

Leave a comment

Find Amazing Vendors