(Closed) Let me see your Cakes!

posted 4 years ago in Food
Post # 2
719 posts
Busy bee

How much are you being charged?  $8-$10 per person is normal in my neck of the woods.  Double that for silvia weinstock or Ron Ben Israel.

Post # 4
8005 posts
Bumble Beekeeper

We’re in the process of doing cake tastings and such. Depending on add ons, most places around here are about $4/serving with an additional delivery fee. Some of the places don’t charge extra in terms of decorating unless you want fondant or something, and even then, it seemed pretty reasonable to me.

Why are you only doing one cake tasting? There are lots of great cake bakers out there, and you might be able to get a better deal elsewhere.

Post # 5
733 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2014

This was our cake. It was $575 which included delivery/set up of the cake. It tasted amazing with 3 different kinds of cake : Red Velvet with vanilla butter cream, Chocolate with Chocolate butter cream and Marble with Vanilla butter cream. This cake fed 115-130 people and not every ate cake so we had tons left over for about a week and a half after the wedding (had to keep giving it away to friends/family).  We did cake tastings at 2 different places but mainly the first one because we were recommeded them by a friend but I knew I wanted to go with the bakery I chose as they have tons of experience and we love their cakes and baked goods.

Post # 6
597 posts
Busy bee

We had a scrumptious naked strawberry shortcake cake! It ended up costing I think almost $7 a slice/per person but it was so worth it cause it was so delicious!

Post # 8
773 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2014 - Gold Hill Gardens


I can’t remember how much ours came to. I think about $650 for 100 people. We had two flavors – chocolate cake with Oreo buttercream and white cake with raspberry buttercream filling. The Oreo layers were the best 🙂 no charge for delivery, because we were inside her “range.”

Post # 9
707 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2014 - Jacksonville Inn

Our cake was $200, which I think was a steal! We had 3 flavors – carrot cake with cream cheese filling, white cake with strawberry filling and chocoalte cake with a chocolate mousse filling, all frosted with pale pink better cream.

Post # 10
61 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: October 2014

Mine was $280 a friend of a friend made it. It tasted great, I just got the chocolate mud cake. There was plently left over we used the top for Darling Husband birthday a couple of weeks after. 

Post # 11
79 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: Detroit

We got our wedding cake from a the local bakery that we typically use for holiday desserts and special events.  It was DELICIOUS– chocolate cake with raspberry mousse.  I think we paid around $1000 for it.  We served the botton 4 tiers to 160 people and kept the top one.

Post # 12
2837 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: November 2013

MrsHistory-Bee:  I feel like cakes are more picture props than anything– even if they taste good, I don’t feel like many people savor the cake– especially for $12/ serving.


I know this is not what you’re likely looking for, but this was our “cake”


I wanted something more fun– they were a huge hit, elegantly done, and were like $1.50 each.

Post # 13
107 posts
Blushing bee

Did I miss a description of what kind of cake you are looking for?  What is making it more expensive/person?

Cakes are expensive to make! That is for sure.  I recently made a three tier for a friend, and it cost me 150.00 just in ingredients.  Not to mention my time involved, pans, etc.

Money conversations are hard, and awkward.  But I think asking the future in laws what they are able to put towards the cake will at least give you a starting point.  Also maybe looking online with them at some bakery sites and prices will help.  Most do not understand what the cakes cost these days, everything is more expensive than what we think it should be. 

Post # 14
2070 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

Ours was made by a family friend. She very kindly only charged us for the ingredients so it cost £200 and fed 200 people! We had 3 flavours: chocolate, coffee and walnut and fruit cake. 🙂

Post # 15
57 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: April 2015

hyzenthlay:  Your cake was seriously beautiful!!

The topic ‘Let me see your Cakes!’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors