Looking for Caribbean Travel Advice

posted 1 month ago in Travel
Post # 2
13597 posts
Honey Beekeeper
  • Wedding: November 1999

It’s outside the Caribbean, but Bermuda is one of my all-time favorite relaxing beach vacations. 

Post # 3
419 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: May 2012

futuremrspk :  I’ve lived in Antigua! Also been to St Lucia, St Martin, Barbados, Guadeloupe, Dominica (not the DR) Puerto Rico and Aruba, Curacoa and St Thomas (the last 3 very briefly on a cruise). And not all of the Bahamas was affected so it’s still worth a look. Feel free to ask any questions!

Antigua, St Martin and Barbados all have beautiful beaches. February is my favourite time of year to travel to the Caribbean, the weather is as good as it gets in my opinion 🙂

Post # 4
2796 posts
Sugar bee

Why is the Bahamas out? There are many more islands than the ones hit by the hurricane. 

That said, I second Bermuda. 

Post # 5
1115 posts
Bumble bee

Why not Puerto Rico? I’ve been there a couple times, and it’s large enough that there’s lots to do as well as many gorgeous beaches that aren’t overrun with tourists. 

Post # 6
604 posts
Busy bee

Highly recommend Great Exuma Island. It was not affected by Dorian, has stunningly beautiful beaches, is low-key and absolute PARADISE. You can find an economical rental and there are many activities of which to take advantage. The snorkeling is top notch. Locals are so wonderful. It is just a magical place. But if you go expecting a resort experience…it is not that (and to me, that’s a good thing!). 

Post # 7
9 posts

What do you think about cruise vacation? Not everyone likes it but personally, I think it’s one of the best ways to visit several countries. I’ve been on three cruises, It is wonderful. No stress of planning where you go, looking for great restaurants etc. Highly recommend thinking about it https://travelsites.com/best-cruise-sites/

Post # 9
6631 posts
Bee Keeper

Aruba is very arid, so think more desert/cactus vs lush rainforest. I’d nix it if you’re looking for nature adventure. 

Post # 10
111 posts
Blushing bee

I just got back from 4 Nights all incl. vacation in Jamaica. I stayed 4 nights at Grand Palladium resort incl flight from orlando ( or other place in US ) paid only 689 all in. ( flights, transfer from airport, hotel oceanview ) Jamaica is pretty and people is fun 🙂 

Post # 11
3417 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: January 2021

Have you consit Costa Rica? As non partier, outdoorsy types it seems like a great fit! No sense wasting your money on all inclusive resorts that cater to big drinkers. 

Post # 12
7002 posts
Busy Beekeeper
  • Wedding: September 2012

sboom :  I agree with this.

futuremrspk :   Costa Rica is one of those desitnations that is a perfect fit for so many different types of people! All-inclusives can be a great option for people because they are more cost-effictive but I feel like AI’s are meant for the non-adventurous vacationer. It has beaches, mountains, hiking, etc. I would split my time between the Arenal Volcano area to experience the beauty of the rainforrest and adventure activies and then spend the second part at the beach. We usually go near Jaco, but the only downside is you aren’t getting those white sand beaches.

Don’t count out the Bahamas. It’s a massive chaine and there are plenty of islands that were not affected by the hurricane and they gladly welcome your tourism to help get their country back on it’s feet. 

Bermuda is nice, but IMO it’s very expensive for what it is. Certainly not for the budget traveler. 

When you say on a budget, what does that mean? Budget concious means different things to different people. At the end of the day the most cost-effective options is probably going to be an AI in the Cancun area. Flights into CUN are abundant and often reasonable, and you can pick a nice AI and spend your days on the beach with all meals + drinks included.

Post # 13
376 posts
Helper bee

I feel like I’ve been to almost every island in the Caribbean. My favorites are Turks and Caicos and Aruba. Turks and Caicos had the best water and beaches and food in my opinion. Aruba has perfect weather. We are actually going to Aruba in February and Turks and Caicos in May. Aruba is overall a great vacation and usually more reasonable prices than Turks and Caicos and the food is good.

My least favorites by far were Jamaica and Dominican Republic.

I enjoyed Puerto Rico, St Thomas, Bermuda, Bahamas, St Lucia, Antigua, and Grand Cayman  but I just loved Turks and Caicos so much more. 

For a nature outdoorsy vacation I would see about Costa Rica, too, the beaches arent’a always WHITE sand with that super blue water, some are “black” sand beaches but it’s great for outdoor activities.

Post # 14
442 posts
Helper bee


Post # 15
3848 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: November 2016

futuremrspk :  I’ve been to a lot of Caribbean islands and they’re all gorgeous!  Like PP said, not all of the Bahamas was impacted by Dorian – I would not rule that out.  I am going to Exuma later this year and super excite!  I have never been, but my family says that it is their favorite location. 

Personally St. Lucia was my favorite island to date.  They have hot springs, hiking, and gorgeous beaches.  It is a very lush island (as is Antigua).  Aruba is also beautiful if you’re looking for perfect beaches – they also have trade winds which make the hot temperatures more pleasant; however, it is pretty flat and desert-y.  

Leave a comment

Find Amazing Vendors