Making a Murderer Thread Part 2

posted 2 years ago in The Lounge
  • poll: Is Steven Avery guilty?



    Still not sure

    I think they both did it.

  • Post # 31
    43 posts

    I dont “know” if SA is guilty or innocent, but I do know that based on the evidence he is not guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt”. There is definitely doubt. 

    Post # 32
    1533 posts
    Bumble bee

    I don’t think he is innocent. I think he was involved somethow. But he shouldn’t be in jail. There is enough of reasonable doubt.

    Post # 33
    156 posts
    Blushing bee
    • Wedding: September 2019 - City, State

    My opinion is that they’re both innocent, but I know I’m not getting the whole story either. There’s plenty of things that are sketchy AF though and it makes me sick to think of innocent people being imprissoned. In the first season my Fiance and I both felt like there was something shady about Bobby, and after this season… it seems more likely that he could be the one that did it. There’s something off about the ex situation as well.

    Id also like to hear why he’s a “monster”. He’s spent most of his life in jail so what can you really know about him? As far as I know he hasn’t caused troubles within the jail. Perhaps he did shitty things as a younger person but that doesn’t equate to being a monster or murderer either… They come across as simple people to me. Not manipulative or brutal. But I never actually met them 

    Post # 34
    576 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: December 2018 - City, State

    My biggest issue with the justice system is the lack of justice….

    Its clear attorneys are not interested in the facts but in making a get a conviction so they can stamp the case closed.

    Its clear that Brendan is lying because he says he was at a place when his mum is even like “brendan you were home with me wtf u talking about???”… the slitting of the throat? where is all the blood? where is thr evidence to support it? When asked about this they said he had 5 days to clean up??? for real. they cleaned gallons of blood but didnt pick up a key? and that house was a tip lol. 

    Maybe I need to be there to hear it but the biggest questions I have arent answered and they seem to be obvious questions? 

    Please falsely confess alot.

    Leave a comment

    Find Amazing Vendors