(Closed) MOH Dilemma— help!!

posted 6 years ago in Bridesmaids
Post # 3
837 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: October 2012

@jlbasford:  I’m sorry that I don’t have a suggestion, but I do have a question. It’s just a matter of curiosity / trying to understand and isn’t meant to come across as judgmental, so I hope it doesn’t.

As it is your wedding, why do you feel that you should include your sister in your wedding party? If you’re not close, you’re not close. Do you think it would be awkward to have her included in the wedding party (especially as your maid of honor, if that’s the route you took) when you and (most likely) she will know that she’s there out of a sense of obligation, rather than genuine, 100% desire to have her there in that capacity, especially considering that she could bring drama and be miserable? Would it make your wedding / planning experience better or worse to have her be part of the whole thing? 

For me, the answer would be simple. I don’t feel that family automatically gets a special spot in the wedding just because they are family, just as I don’t feel that family has a “right” to be there at all. But I know that plenty of (if not most) people believe that being related (something you have no control over) trumps people who are in your life by choice and who are there for you because you grew close instead of just growing up in the same home. 

Post # 4
41 posts
  • Wedding: September 2013

I agree. Your sister doesn’t need to be in the bridal party, especially if she’s going to cause drama.

But if you want them both in the party, they will have to be civil to each other. If they love you they will.

Post # 5
1141 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: July 2012

I disagree I’m afraid. I think sisters should be in the wedding party. Family is for life. It sounds like your younger sister is jealous of your best friend and could be hurt that she’s not close. Could you talk to her to ask if she’s willing to behave? Honestly just not addressing it could cause drama all by itself. I would at least have a talk about if she could suck it up for your best friend.

Post # 6
5963 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: April 2018

Hey, I’m stuck in this EXACT situation….best friend just got engaged and wanted me and her older sister to be dual MOH’s, when she asked me I was thrilled!  Many hands make light work and besides, it’s whatever she wants, right?  WRONG!  When she asked her sister to share the honor she hit the ceiling!  Screamed at the bride, made her cry, then called the parents and kicked up a fuss over the budget…not cool!  So now we’re in this awkward no talking stage, it’s been a week, no word from the sister and the bride has to rally and call her after her sister was the one that made a mistake….it’s really awful.  I can’t make the decision for you, but your Maid/Matron of Honor should be your go-to person, your wingman, the get-er dun girl and emotional dumpster, if your sister can’t do that, which is doesn’t sound like she can, I would choose the one that I could count on, drama be damned…..it’s a wedding, not a political coup.  Pick the ones you want with you and find another way to make your sister feel special.  Just because she’s not the Maid/Matron of Honor doesn’t mean she can’t have a special dress, corsage…whatever….

Post # 7
1375 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2012

If you haven’t asked anyone, I’d highly suggest waiting until you’re no more than a year out from your wedding to ask your bridal party.  Relationships change, and I’m sure you’ve seen posts from brides saying they asked people too soon and now are trying to ‘remove’ their friends from bridal parties – a definite no-no!

Then, once you have a year until your wedding, look at your friendships and relationships.  Who would you call at 3 AM to hide a body?  That’s your Maid/Matron of Honor.  Who would you tell the next morning and swear them to secrecy?  Those are your bridesmaids.

Post # 8
80 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: July 2014

@jlbasford:  I have the same dilemma 🙁 I have a twin sister but we don’t exactly get along. But she EXPECTS to be my Maid/Matron of Honor although I would absolutely LOVE my best friend to be my Maid/Matron of Honor. And aside from the whole issue of that.. my sister has always had some kind of jealously towards me and does anything in her power to “ruin” anything I look forward to (ex my wedding!!). I don’t want to compromise having who I want to have as a Maid/Matron of Honor, but I don’t want any EXTRA drama at all, so my SO and I have decided that when we do decide to get married, we will go away to Niagara Falls with just our parents and have a big party when we get back, that I can tell both of them they would have been my Maid/Matron of Honor and they can help however they wish with no drama or pressure. Obvisouly going away to get married is not an option for everyone… but that’s what we decided to keep the sister drama away. Kind of sucks in a way that we have to run away.. but i’m sure you totally understand!

Post # 11
202 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: May 2013

I have a friend that had two maids of honor.  You could definitely do that.  And if you would rather your friend take on most of the event planning duties, then you can ask her to do that.


Post # 12
617 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2014

I would do what makes you happy.  Ultimately it is your day.  I think in general you do need to include her in the bridal party.  Think of how hurt you would be if she did not include you in hers.  However, as far as your Maid/Matron of Honor goes I think you should go with your heart on this one. I know plenty of brides who have sisters but have used their best friends as their Maid/Matron of Honor.  Do what YOU want, not what everyone else wants.

By any chance have you considered having 2 MOH’s ?


The topic ‘MOH Dilemma— help!!’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors