Post # 1
i had a moissanite that I loved but it was a stand-in. I now have an ideal cut EX/EX/EX diamond and I cannot lie, nothing compares to the fire of moissanite. In some lights I swear I couldn’t tell the difference between the two. I may go back to moissanite in the end!
Pics for comparison.
1.73 I/SI1 ideal cut diamond:
8mm F1 moissanite:
Post # 2
Interesting, maybe the differences just aren’t as obvious IRL, but I think the diamond looks much crisper and clearer and has better arrows. 🤷♀️
Post # 3
I also wonder if the differences are less obvious in person. The moissanite looks more flat in the pictures, like it lacks depth.
Post # 4
i think it’s fair to say the diamond has more dimension/depth, but the moissanite definitely has more fire.
Post # 5
That’s interesting because I have diamonds and a moissanite and I prefer the moissanite too. I enjoy wearing it more and catch myself admiring it much more. Your rings are gorgeous by the way!
Post # 6
Depends what you like. I didn’t like moissanite precisely because of the “fire” , it’s sparkle with light seemed vastly different to a diamonds sparkle. So since we were on a budget we went for a lab grown diamond. It depends on each person and their preferences runningmama :
Post # 7
Your moissy is stunning!! Can I ask where you got it? It is crisp and clear but not too “stark”
Post # 8
If you prefer the moissanite then go for it! I preferred the look of diamonds (but I was also looking at ovals) and figured my one special ring ought to be what I wanted
Post # 9
Can I ask about the clarity rating of that diamond? From the pictures, it doesn’t have visible inclusions but those arrows are not dark. That can happen due to clouds or a haze, which can cause a lower clarity that looks eye clean. That might not be what’s happening, but it would affect a diamonds performance.
I prefer my diamond. I don’t like the rainbow flashes. I love the depth and clean arrows. When I take pictures, my arrows always show up dark.
I have only seen moissanite at Helzberg. I think I may order earrings in moissanite just so I can see what they’re like.
Post # 10
- Wedding: March 2014 - Chicago, IL
I think it’s hard to pick up a difference in photos, but having had both myself, I have appreciation for both. The moissanite has more fire, but looks kind of fuzzy and plasticy in comparison. The diamond has more white light return, depth and looks crisper in person.
In one of these pics below, the diamond is set, and in the other pic, the moissanite is set. You reeeeallly have to know what you’re looking for to see the difference. Because of that, I honestly encourage anyone on the fence about moissanite to just go for the moissanite. If mine didn’t have an impossible-to-remove oil slick stain, then I would’ve kept it over the diamond. I think something about the Forever Brilliant OECs makes this problem worse than other versions, but that’s just speculation.
Post # 11
Unset one looks like moissanite, lacks depth and looks slightly plastic. Especially under the table.
I have both and wanted to prefer moissanite but had to prefer the sharpness and depth of diamond. Moissanite is still a very beautiful stone but even though it sparkles more, the sparkles seem lazier and off the surface instead of scintillating from within.
Luckily lab diamonds are making big strides and will likely be more and more affordable!
Post # 12
runningmama : I have both, and can definitely tell the difference at a glance, although I’ve had a jeweler assume my moissy was a diamond.
I prefer the look of diamond, but couldn’t justify the price. My 2nd hand moissy in 14c white gold was $400AUD. equiv. look in a diamond is like $6000.
Post # 13
Interesting perspectives! I do agree about the moissanite plastic appearance. My moissy was a Charles and Covard.
i realize my issue is with my diamond. It looks really blue in sunlight with brown undertone, and definitely brown (not warm, actually brown) in other lighting. I’m going to return it and get a stone with better specs. I think that will make a world of difference.
Post # 14
I have found also that my moissanite doesn’t photograph particularily well. I love the way it looks in person, but I always find it looking a little ‘flat’ and less crisp in pictures than I feel it looks in person
Post # 15
runningmama : strong blue fluorescence? That could easily cause that haziness I was mentioning, causing less crisp arrows. Fluorescence is super tricky.