(Closed) [POLL] Moissanite vs Amora Gem vs Diamond

posted 5 years ago in Rings
  • poll: What was your decision?
    Moissanite, no regrets! : (28 votes)
    35 %
    Amora Gem, no regrets! : (11 votes)
    14 %
    Moissanite, regretted it, and went back to diamonds : (5 votes)
    6 %
    Amora Gem, regretted, and went back to diamonds : (1 votes)
    1 %
    Diamonds are a girl's best friend, never considered any dupes! : (36 votes)
    44 %
  • Post # 2
    Member
    2814 posts
    Sugar bee
    • Wedding: November 2015 - City, State

    These two have been discussed to death… Just use the search function to look up info. on moissanite and amora gem.

    And as far as prices, go to each of their websites and look at the prices yourself in the carat ranges you’re interested in.

    http://www.betterthandiamond.com

    http://www.moissaniteco.com

    Post # 3
    Member
    98 posts
    Worker bee
    • Wedding: September 2010

    Amora is less expensive than Amora Gem. Amora gem costs in the range of $750 per carat average, but it’s specific to the stone depending on its color, size, and clarity.

    I personally do not like moissanite but I do have an Amora Gem ring that I wear when my diamond would not be appropriate or I’m worried about damage. None of the three really look anything like each other to be honest. I still prefer diamonds, but my amora gem is pretty cool.

    The honest answer is price is the biggest reason to buy a simulant. Others will disagree, ethical mining etc but it doesn’t hurt that the price is so much less than a comparable diamond.

    If you like rounds, the simulants have pretty much been perfected. The jury is out a bit more on the fancy shapes – I don’t care for the moissanite cushion cut, but then again, I don’t like most diamond cushion cuts either. So it really depends what you want your ring to look like and what you want to spend on said ring.

    Post # 4
    Member
    5221 posts
    Bee Keeper

    maocat:  I don’t think you can go wroung with any of them, tbh. I have a diamond, and I love my diamond, but I’ve seen some moissy on here that has brought a tear to my eye. 

    Your best bet would be to see them in person and then decide. I think you can order a loose moissanite and return it if it isn’t for you. I’m not as sure about the amora gem. 

    What does yor Fiance prefer? Some guys are traditionalists and only want a diamond. 

    Post # 5
    Member
    9588 posts
    Buzzing Beekeeper
    • Wedding: September 2015

    It is a better option for some because it is a fraction of the price (There are loads of ethical diamonds and lab diamonds but they’re just as $$$).  If you don’t care at all about having a diamond, I don’t see the sense in paying for one. They’re crazy expensive.

    From pics on here and buyer anecdotes I can say- moissanite is much warmer/moodier than amora gem. You can get a D-F equivalent AG but moissanite is much much more yellow/green, so weigh if that will bug you or not. If it will, go for the amora gem. Maybe order a ring with a return policy just to see?

    There’s also the oil spill recurring stain phenomena on both so Id be prepared and okay with that. It seems the only people disappointed with their moissanite are the ones that truly wanted a diamond, and expected their moissy to behave the same way. 

    I would search the archives- there’s a million threads on the topic. 

    Post # 6
    Member
    10573 posts
    Sugar Beekeeper
    • Wedding: December 2013

    I’ve had all 3. And i love each one for their own unique properties. So it’s really a matter of what you like. If your going for a stone that looks like a diamond then your best bet is to get a diamond! Amora gem looks more diamond like than moissanite but it still doesn’t perform exactly like a diamond would. I love how sparkly moissanite is but it’s less diamond like than the amora gem due to its cut, warmth, and intense fire/rainbow sparkle but it’s still a gorgeous stone! You should definitely order a loose moissy and amora gem if possible. That way you can compare and maybe take them into a jewelery store to see how they compare to a diamond.

    Post # 7
    Member
    2001 posts
    Buzzing bee
    • Wedding: October 2017

    maocat:  

    1. low price with a diamond look. Which is why I am getting a FB moissy and eventually upgrading to a real diamond.

    2. I would get the amora gem if planning to keep it permanently because although there are  reviews that it can appear white, milky or plasticy it is cut less shallowly and more like a real diamond than moissy. Have only seen 1 complaint so far about staining. Moissanite has had lots of complaints of the staining thing. Plus even the enhanced moissy reflects yellow, green , gray tones sometimes. 

    3. 1 carat high quality round diamond in simple 4 prong white gold setting:  $8,000.

        1 carat  equiv wt round FB missanite in a simple 4 prong white gold setting: $495.

        1 carat dia equivalent wt round amora gem in a simple 4 prong white gold $850.

    If ethics are a concern, there are ethical issues with jewelry metal but recycled gold is available The manufacturing and processing of Moissanite, amora gem has issues. Moissanite is cut in poor third world countries and some of the jewery is made there, plus there are waste issues from the manufacturing process. Diamonds have the kimberly process but that is flawed as well.  Buying used may be a good option.

    Post # 8
    Member
    246 posts
    Helper bee

    Not seeing lots of posts on here about sapphires – but I went with a white sapphire and love it!  They are the second most durable next to diamonds (I think) – and in my opinion are still way gorgeous – without the higher price tag of a diamond!

    Post # 9
    Member
    35 posts
    Newbee

    I have a round brilliant amora moissanite as my center stone in my engagement ring. I love it! Everyone always thinks it’s a diamond until I correct them. Super super sparkly, people at work always comment that they can see it shining from across the room, especially when it’s clean lol. My stone doesn’t really have much warmth, it’s very white. However, it does spark different colors in light, which I love. I also love that my fiance was able to get a beautiful stone with a much lower pricetag, and put more money into a more unique setting. But, everyone has their own preferences! I think each stone is beautiful for different reasons

    Post # 10
    Member
    246 posts
    Helper bee

    I agree – I think there are great things about all stones – and I’m really glad to see lots of ladies are going with other options besides diamonds – there are lots of great choices out there when it comes to different gemstones!  For me, size is more important than perfection – so a gemstone was more practical (price-wise) in this sense.  🙂

    Post # 11
    Member
    1392 posts
    Bumble bee

    I don’t want a diamond, I want a colored sapphire…but if I had to choose between the options, I’d probably go with diamond, unless we could only afford a really small one, then moissanite.

    Post # 12
    Member
    4258 posts
    Honey bee
    • Wedding: February 2009

    I have all three and love them all.  If I had to sacrifice size to get the a diamond, I would not.  I would get an AG.  I like the whiteness better than the warmness of moissy.  But if I coould get the size I wanted in diamond, I would always pick diamond.  I also have white sapphire, and they are pretty dull compared to the others, and need a lot of cleaning like CZ, so I would stay away from that.

    The topic ‘[POLL] Moissanite vs Amora Gem vs Diamond’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors