Moissanite VS Diamond, which to get?

posted 3 years ago in Rings
  • poll: Moissanite or Diamond?
    Moissanite : (26 votes)
    38 %
    Diamond : (41 votes)
    60 %
    Other (comment other gemstone) : (1 votes)
    1 %
  • Post # 16
    9828 posts
    Buzzing Beekeeper
    • Wedding: March 2014 - Chicago, IL

    View original reply
    mrsptobe2017 :  IMO, that’s true, but the metal in your setting, unless recycled negates it. Also, if you have diamond melee, that negates it too. 

    View original reply
    tiskaren :  Go with a diamond. I have a moissanite and find myself lusting after a diamond. I originally wanted a diamond, but a coworker of mine got a moissanite and the fire/brilliance blew me away so I jumped on board. It allowed me to get a bigger stone and the setting of my dreams. I’m a scientist so being that it’s lab created was actually a plus. And back then, lab diamonds weren’t bigger than 3/4 ct. BUT, if I could do it all over again, I would max out my budget for the stone (diamond, either antique or lab created), go with a simple setting and upgrade the setting down the road. I am one of those people that gets a reoccuring stain (“oil slick”) on the table and facets of my moissanite. It goes away with cleaning, but it’s annoying.


    Post # 17
    1460 posts
    Bumble bee

    Go with what you have your heart set on.  I have diamonds and love them and have no regrets ever that we went with a diamond.  I did have a moissanite that I wore on vacation, but it just never gave me the same feeling. I often felt people knew I was wearing a sim when they looked at my hand with the moissy, but it was beauitful.  But when I wear my diamond everyday, it always gives me this feeling of awe and makes me happy.  So go with what would make you happy and what you can afford – you can’t go wrong with either choice as long as it makes you happy!

    Post # 18
    2513 posts
    Sugar bee
    • Wedding: September 2018

    Search the other 5,000 threads on the topic 

    Post # 19
    5602 posts
    Bee Keeper

    If you’re on a budget, just get a big gorgeous moissanite and save yourself the time.  I also recommend buying the stone used, try ebay or diamondbistro, you’ll save a fortune.  Put it in a setting you love and call it a day.  Later on you can upgrade to whatever you want.

    Post # 22
    652 posts
    Busy bee


    Oh, absolutely – if a freshly created moissanite or a newly mined diamond are the only options, moissanite is much more ethical. However, I always think it’s interesting when ethics is the main motivation for moissanite – an antique or vintage diamond is the only true no-impact solution. However, as marriedalready69 pointed out, there is a good marketplace for secondhand moissanite, so that’s definitely something to consider.

    <div> </div>
    <div>I always thought moissanite being made without mining was a nice additional perk for someone who was attracted to the unique sparkle, the consistent quality, and the attractive pricing, or someone who loved the science behind a lab created stone  – if ethics is the driving factor, doesn’t a stoneless ring or vintage ring make more sense? Of course no ring at all is the most ethical option. </div>
    <div> </div>
    <div>Considering my phone was made by child slaves, I eat chocolate, and I live in a country I only get to inhabit because its original occupants were brutally slaughtered, I thought an engagement ring was the wrong hill to die on re: ethics. I have a newly mined sapphire with diamond sidestones.</div>
    <div> </div>
    <div>However, I did try to at least minimize the impact by tracing the source mine my sapphire came from (allegedly, who knows if it’s all fabricated), and using recycled gold and Canadian diamonds.</div>
    <div> </div>
    <div>But I’d never consider my ring ethical. It’s a pretty indulgence that I wanted, not a political statement. </div>

    Post # 22
    77 posts
    Worker bee

             Go with the moissanite! I am obsessed with mine! If you get a quality stone you will have no green or yellow. You get a ring with more sparkle, and more stone for your money with moissanite. Charles and covard produce pretty much every moissanite on the market and have an exellent warranty for the stone. My only advice is since you want a halo get all the small stones in diamonds and your main stone a Moissanite. Aparently moissanite in the smaller size doesn’t hold up as well as diamonds. 

    Leave a comment

    Find Amazing Vendors