My bestfriend has the same engagement ring with me!!!

posted 2 years ago in Rings
Post # 2
393 posts
Helper bee

View original reply
llulu :  Can we see your ring?

I understand how you might feel uncomfortable having an identical ring to your best friend…a lot of people want some semblance of uniqueness to their ring, especially in their circle of friends. However, when you pick a popular ring (or anything, really), this can be hard to do. A solitaire with a halo is super common right now, as you said yourself. If you picked a popular metal and a popular cut, that’s even more difficult. What if your friend wanted the same style, not because it’s yours, but because it’s what she likes?

I would feel more awkward in your friend’s shoes but this really depends on the specifics of the ring.

Post # 3
5551 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: October 2017

I think your reaction to this is really, really extreme. You can’t look at your ring, you can’t wear it, you can’t be around them…

You encouraged him to propose to her, you gave him your ring as inspiration, and he went with that probably thinking his girlfriend would love it.

I think you need to find out why you are having such an extreme reaction to this

Post # 4
10602 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
  • Wedding: City, State

You have an extremely basic ring. If you wanted to be the only one in your circle with that style of ring you should have gotten something more unique.

Post # 5
793 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: May 2018 - Farm

View original reply
llulu :  Your ring and relationship has no significance to her relationship and her ring. You are two different couples with different relationships. You’re putting more importance on you two having the same ring when it has no impact on your relationship. So what if she has the same ring. No it’s not clothing but I don’t understand why such an uproar when the style of ring you picked out is very common.  You’re being dramatic. It may have been the style that she wanted. You don’t know. 

Post # 6
71 posts
Worker bee

As her bestfriend I don’t get why you’re having this kind of reaction. I know it’s annoying when you think someone is copying you, but she’s your best friend. Wouldn’t you be more happy for them now that they’re engaged? Also, your ring style is very common. What if she just really likes that style long before you even got engaged? 

Post # 7
1248 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: September 2017

Boo. Freakin. Hoo.

Post # 8
1171 posts
Bumble bee

So? Get over it. This is such a non-issue. 

Post # 9
13609 posts
Honey Beekeeper

You are being totally unreasonable. That is an extremely common and popular style. My advice is to get over it. 

Post # 10
1456 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: November 2019

View original reply
mrscb2bee :  HA! 


Yeah, sorry OP, I think you’re over reacting. It sounds like you have a very common and popular ring and it would stand to reason that your friend might like the same style. Be happy for your friends and move on. 

Post # 11
910 posts
Busy bee

even though this is a “new” user, the misspelling and grammar issues remind me of another poster from yesterday who had an extreme post…

Post # 12
4208 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: November 2019 - Canada

I get being a little upset that her ring is identical to yours, but in the grand scheme of things, does this really even matter? Your reaction is way over the top.

Take a second and think about all the good in your life. You’re engaged to the love of your life, and now so is your best friend. She’s been wanting this for a while and it’s happening now! Stop focussing on one tiny little detail and start being happy for your best friend. If you cant do that, you’re really not as good of friends as you thought.  Put your damn ring on, love it like you did the day before your friend got engaged and just be happy that she’s happy! 

Post # 13
2523 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: August 2018

View original reply
llulu :  How old are you? You sound 12.

My ring is the exact same as my best friends, as well as god knows how many other women since it’s a plain solitaire ring. It doesn’t change how special MY ring is just because other people have the same style… 

Put your ring on, be grateful, and be happy for your friend.

Post # 14
53 posts
Worker bee

Your ring is the style that is most common right now, every single jewelry store carries it. 90% of the people engaged in the last few years probably have it. I love the style, sounds like you do too but she must too. You need to get this out of your head before you see her. Say congratulations and be happy for her. If that’s not your only reaction you are going to look petty and kind of crazy. 

Post # 15
2847 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: November 2018

Sorry chicka, but unless you pick a super unique or custom made setting- someone is bound to have the same one. 

In your case you have an EXTREMELY common setting. Like thousands and thousands have the exact same ring as you. You’re going to have to get over it. 

Leave a comment

Find Amazing Vendors