Post # 1
So I need some help. My e-ring is unusual, .75 princess cut with a double halo, infinty shank. I have it paired with my wedding band, which is a super thin eternity band. I thought it needed a little something. I found this infinity eternity band at tiffany & co, but I’m not sure how I feel. I can return the band, so please be candid with your opinions. Is it too much? Does the silver tiffany ring look odd because it’s not white gold? my husband says he likes it either way. I played around with how I have them stacked, so if you do like it..it would be great if you could let me know which way.
Thanks SO much for the help!
Post # 2
Mamalovesgracie12: I like it!
I think I like it best with the eternity ring on the bottom, the way you have it in the last few pictures. I feel like, somehow, it transitions from your ERing’s “busy” (for lack of a better word — I don’t mean that in a negative way at all because your ERing is beautiful!) band to the more streamlined look of the eternity band. Also, I like how the silver band blends in with your ERing’s band but doesn’t totally blend in. I hope this makes sense. I don’t feel like I am expressing myself very well. >.O
I like a wide set, too. I may be in the minority on that one — ha, ha!
Post # 4
Personally, return it. The whole idea of a “stack” is insane and ridiculous to me and your engagement ring and wedding band are lovely together. If you feel the need to add something, get another matching band so it is symmetrical on both sides. But the infinity ring doesn’t go.
Post # 5
i don’t like the silver ring with it at all. Stick with the e-ring and wedding band.
Post # 6
I like the infinity band but not the whole thing together. Do you plan on always wearing the engagement ring? I’m asking because the infinity band and eternity band would look really nice together.
I have stacked rings but I will only wear them when I can’t wear my engagement ring because of work.
Post # 7
I far prefer it without the silver ring.
Post # 8
- Wedding: November 2009 - New York, NY
I don’t like the Tiffany band with your set.
Post # 9
I love the stack with the eternity band at the bottom! It all depends on what you want – it doesnt matter what anyone else thinks. We all have different tastes
Post # 10
It looks ok with the tiffany band but I like it better without. Plus it’s silver and your white gold rings will scratch it terribly. If you really like the band you should keep it. How you feel about it is all that matters. I do think it would look good as a right hand ring. Have you considered getting another diamond band that’s slightly different then your current band, or maybe even a thin plain white gold band would look nice? If you really want to add a third ring then I’d go to several jewelry stores and try some on to see what you like best. I think you should try something in rose gold but I’m biased 🙂
Post # 11
I’m not a big fan of the eternity ring with your ER and wedding band. The silver definitely looks like a different colour, which would bother me but I know a lot of other people intentionally mismatch their sets. I think your ER and WB look fabulous together without the other ring. If you were to add another ring, I’d go with another diamond band, perhaps in a different shape or pattern if you wanted to add interest.
Post # 12
I like it better without – too busy.
Post # 13
Thanks everyone!! I actually decided to return it and ran over last night. I like some of your suggestions with another band at the top. Again thank you all so much for your opinions!