Post # 1
Ok here is the dilemma! My husband got my first wedding band for me (a .50 band) to go well with my 1.25 blue diamond center stone in a .50 beautiful setting and then decided to get me another one (.50 band) for our 5 year mark this year. So I went online looking for the same one he bought me before (it was bought on Ebay from a GREAT reliable seller) and I thought I found the right one that matched perfect. Well I got the ring in the mail yesterday and noticed the band size is a bit thicker so the ring looks a bit bigger than the first one. So they are not the same size. I don’t know if it’s extremely noticeable and looks bad. So I thought I would get opinions on here!! Please tell me your thoughts. I really like the size of the new band and there is nothing I can really do about the different sizes of the bands so I might just be stuck with it. I am hoping I can get use to it and it won’t drive me insane!! Any way here are photos, tell me your thoughts! Thanks ladies! Any opinions or pictures of your beautiful sets will help!
This is kinda a side view of what the 2 bands look like with the engagement ring.
The first wedding band is on top and the newer one is on bottom.
Post # 3
If I didnt see them side by side in the 3rd photo, I wouldve never known they were different.
Post # 4
When you where them with your engagement ring in the middle, you can’t even tell the size difference. All the bands look great together I think 🙂
Post # 5
I think they look great.
And the blue diamond is to die for.
Post # 6
I agree with MASPA I couldnt really tell till the last pic. If you think it will drive you crazy then send it back. If you think you can live with it…no one will really notice but you. Good luck!
Post # 7
If you didn’t mention it I would have never noticed. Your set is amazing btw
Post # 8
I think it’s fine because you can’t even tell they’re different until you point it out.
Post # 9
Agree with everyone else. With the engagement ring in the middle you cant even tell. Before I scrolled through all the pics I actually went back and re-read your post because I thought I missed something because they looked the exact same to me. IN the 3rd pic you can tell but I dont think anyone will notice ever. PS your e-ring is STUNNING!!!
Post # 10
Everyone is sooo sweet! Thank you so much!! If it’s not noticable I think I can live with it!! I just wanted to check with people and see if it was something they noticed because of course I am going to hehe!! Again thank you for the sweet comment on my ring! I love it!! 😀
Post # 11
It’s such a slight difference, I think they look great. Beautiful set, btw! Love the blue diamond and all that sparkle from the white diamonds 🙂
Post # 12
Beautiful set! I don’t think you need to change a thing.
Post # 13
You can’t even tell! They look great together.
Post # 14
I personally actually prefer varying widths with e-rings and wedding bands. I think it gives a clearer sense that it is a “set” and not all one ring. As long as all the ring sit at the same height off the finger, I would be really happy with all of the rings 🙂