Post # 1
So I am really procrastinating at work!! I was reading an entertainment mag at the gym over lunch today and there was the editorial piece that said Carrie (from SITC) should have ended up with Aidan.
Man – I hated Aidan!! I though his character was such a jackass!!!!! Sure, he was woodsy and whatnot, but I thought he was so manipulative……
So – totally for shits and giggles…take the poll – what do you think??
Post # 3
I liked Aidan better! What part of him was manipulative? It’s so funny how we can all interpret these shows differently.
While I personally liked Aidan better, I totally think Big was a better match for Carrie. They kind of deserved each other, if you know what I mean.
Post # 4
While I personally would have liked Aidan better Big was a much better fit for Carrie (minus all the SATC movie nonsense about leaving her at the altar)
Post # 5
I like Aidan better too.
Big was the manipulative one, he would always show up just when carrie was finally happy with another guy and mess everything up. Big was also too grown up sometimes more like her dad than her boyfriend.
Post # 6
I’m a Big girl here! I also dated an Aiden and a Big and I married my Big so there is no contest 🙂 Once you experience the chemistry of Big, you can never be with an Aiden. It was never meant to be!
Post # 7
I would have stayed with the Russian in Paris and left him for a hotter younger Frenchman.
Post # 8
David Duchovny! Anyone? Anyone?
Post # 9
@Beluga: nothing like an institutionalized man to keep things exciting!
Post # 10
Ron Livingston!!! (I don’t remember his character’s name on SATC)
I am an Aidan fan through and through. 😀
Post # 11
@TinyTina: Berger? Ew! LOL
I’m all for Aiden. Big is that guy that only wants you when he can’t have you. Having been in that situation before, it is totally unappealing to me.
Post # 12
I thought she was crazy for dumping Aidan. I was actually MAD at her.
Post # 13
@aleeshabobeesha: Berger!! Hahah I think that is just because I had a crush on Ron Livingston from when he was in Office Space. 😀
Still gotta go with Aidan though.
Post # 14
haha. i voted for big but i did love me some berger.
big was just… big. he was so right for her. they had their ups and downs but they had some crazy narcotic love for each other. their lifestyles fit better too.
i loved aidan for her when they were together, but i’m a hopeless romantic and wanted carrie to end up with the one man she was really meant for.
Post # 15
@KatyElle: LMAO! Perfect.
Post # 16
I was seriously just (over)thinking about this last night, weird. Big all the way for me.
Big was immature, kinda ridiculous, couldn’t commit and all that. But he didn’t try to mold her into whatever he wanted.
Aidan was controlling. Their first date, he gave her the smoking ultimatum. (Yes I know smoking’s bad. But geez, wait a few dates before you demand someone cold-turkey quits a habit that is notoriously difficult to break.) It was HIS decision to move in together and sell her condo. Also there was one episode where he froze her out without telling her why and she basically had to guess/apologize her way back into his arms again (literally). And anyone remember the scene, sometime after the Big affair (maybe same episode as the freeze-out one?), where he slaps her nicotine patch onto her arm, like actually hits her? Ugh. Not a fan. Although the actor is hot.
[Yes I have been watching many reruns lately….]