(Closed) NY Bees, hotel recommendations please

posted 10 years ago in New York City
Post # 3
2365 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: June 2010

I can’t make any specific suggestions really, because my parents always stay in my neighborhood (Upper East Side) which is not exactly the center of it all.

It sort of depends what you want to be near.  In my opinion, being near Herald Square/Times Square would be TORTURE.  Just full of crowds and nonsense.  I will say that the hotel you are talking about is not really near Central Park.  It’s around 30 blocks away, which is a long walk.  IMO, there’s no benefit to staying near the Empire State Building/Herald Square, because it’s really like a big mall.

Really, for tourists, any area in Manhattan below 96th street is safe.  It just all depends what type of neighborhood you’d like to stay in.  I would personally want to stay downtown (East Village, Lower East Side, West Village) because it’s more fun in terms of restaurants, bars, and shops.  But that might not be the most fun place for someone looking to be in a Times Square type neighborhood.

Post # 4
1929 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: February 2008

Please just don’t stay in Times Square!! 

I don’t know the specific hotel you mentioned, but it is centrally located, near good subways, but not in a particularly exciting neighborhood.  Its also about 30 blocks (1.5 miles) from central park.

what dates are you looking at coming? hotel rates in the city have such a range depending on time of year…

also do you like trendy? just need something clean and comfortable and nice enough? do you want to be in a great neighborhood where you can really experience NYC??

Post # 6
136 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: April 2012

I would suggest my neighborhood (Upper West Side). There are several train lines that will get you anywhere you want to go and we’re right by Central Park. Lots of restaurants and shopping. Further downtown is TriBeCa & Battery City. These are also quiet places but have tons of train lines to take you anywhere you want to go.

Post # 7
9 posts

We stayed in SoHo at the Trump hotel.  My bf got a pretty good deal I believe and it was convenient to everything with a subway stop right out the door.  Plus there are amazing little shops (both small stores and regular name brand one) right around the corner!

Post # 9
1646 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: August 2010

when my parents come visit dh and i, they usually stay at this hotel: http://www.ontheave-nyc.com it’s comfortable and also in a really convenient location, 2 short blocks from the subway as well as walking distance to central park, riverside park, the natural history museum, and tons of great restaurants

Post # 10
63 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: January 2013

I have had friends stay at Jolly Rogers-near the Empire State at 38th and Madison and say good things.

Also, the Washington Square Hotel near Washington Sq Park is cozy and has a great restaurant attached to it.

The topic ‘NY Bees, hotel recommendations please’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors