Post # 1
Ok all! Looking for your opinions. My fiancé would like to upgrade my ring and I have totally fallen in love with the H&A F1s on MoCo. I’m having such a hard time deciding what I’d like most. I thought for sure I would always want a round stone in a white gold setting – since being an adult it has been white gold/silver for everything. Until recently. My fiancé has gotten me two right hand rings in rose gold and I. Love. Them. So much! When looking on MoCo’s Instagram the other day, I spotted an oval cut in a rose gold setting. I instantly fell in love and loved how subtle but yet beautiful the rose gold was with the stone. Now I’m so torn. I don’t know if I will change my mind down the road and feel like white gold/round cut would have been a better, “safe” choice for my e-ring. I know there are post like this all the time and it comes down to what I like in the end, but I’m so indecisive it’s not even funny. Here are the links to the rings so you can see them sparkle 🙂
Feel free to show off your ovals/rounds also!
Post # 2
I have an oval so that’s my vote!
Post # 3
Oh gosh…I literally had this exact same dilemma. Torn between a rose gold plain shanked oval or a round solitaire set in white gold. I decided to go with the oval and I am so happy I did, it’s the perfect ring for me and suits my style. I’ll still always love a classic round solitaire though. I vote oval Bee. Here’s mine :
Post # 4
Definitely rose gold oval! Of course I might be slightly biased 🙂
Post # 5
I personally like round or cushion diamonds, but comparing the two pictures I somehow am more drawn to the oval. It’s just got that little bit of character/softness that the round lacks. Either are beautiful though – and I understand you. I’m currently in a ring dilemma as well!
(Legit just posted this: http://boards.weddingbee.com/topic/help-i-cant-decide-12/)
Post # 6
Love your ring!! Very unique but still timeless
Post # 7
When my husband decided to upgrade my ring, I thought I wanted an oval. I think ovals are beautiful! But when I tried on the 1.5 ct round in a rose gold setting, I was sold! So I stuck with the round cut as I truly think that looks better on me (and my hubby liked it more than the oval) and the rose gold setting just made it even more beautiful. I think rose gold is so romantic and pretty and it’s different for me as I’ve always had white gold/platinum. So go with what you LOVE! You won’t regret it.
Post # 8
I had the same dilemma (except I always knew I wanted an oval)! I thought I should pick white gold to be “safe”, but I’m so glad I went with rose gold! It is so beautiful and romantic, and the oval is unique yet still classic. I get compliments on my ring all the time, I’m glad I went with my gut. So I vote rose gold oval! Here’s a picture of my beauty 🙂
Post # 9
abeeinlove : kkkatieB12 : desertbride11417 :
Seriously, these are the kinds of pictures that make me fall in love with the oval/rose gold combo! Such beautiful rings! I’m thinking I may have to go with my gut on this one and go with an oval/rose gold. I honestly don’t see how I could be disappointed in the long run. I think I just have to change my mindset of what my engagement ring “should” look like, since honestly they can be any style. I see so many beautiful and unique ones on here. Thanks for sharing, bees! 🙂
Post # 10
Exactly! Usually the shiny white gold rounds are what I oooh and ahhh over. I obviously love the one I posted which is why I’m torn, but the rose gold/oval is just so captivating to me for some reason!
Btw, I checked out your post! All the rings are very pretty. I think I like the branched one the best! It has the detail without being over the top, and it makes the stone stand out 🙂
Post # 11
Well the bottom line you just cant go wrong either way. They are essentially the same look with slight variations. you should start with the shape first. Go and try both styles on and see which shape and color gold your eye perfers in person. You already love rose gold and have rings so I know you like how it looks on you so if that speaks to you go with it. I ohhh and ahhh over both rounds and ovals. And cushions. Oh and radients and emeralds. And I have a pear. Really anything shiny lol. A pretty sparkly rock is GORGEOUS no matter the shape, size, or type.
Post # 12
If I had a choice I would probably pic the oval. However, I received a round which I am totally in love with.
My SO has an oval though. First pic mine second pic SO
Post # 13
I’m not a huge fan of moissy ovals so my vote if for the round H&A which I think would be lovely in rose gold as well.
Heres my hearts and arrows moissanite in white gold