Overstock ring experiences?

posted 2 years ago in Rings
Post # 2
787 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2019

The quality is pretty bad, I usually see I1-I2 diamonds and they are not GIA graded as well as very heavy settings which really aren’t my fave. Theres way better deals to be had online through the major retailers Etsy or resale

Post # 4
15042 posts
Honey Beekeeper
  • Wedding: June 2011

All their product can be completely different.  I usually rely very heavily on the user reviews for buying stuff on overstock.   I don’t have a ring, but I recently got a moissy pendant from them and love it.  Very well made and soooooooo sparkly. 

Post # 5
107 posts
Blushing bee

I purchased a mossianite ring from Overstock in 2016, it’s beautiful and great quality.  The same ring sells at Helzeberg Diamonds for 3 times the cost.  I wear the ring daily and have never had an issue or problem with it.  I also have another mossianite ring I purchased in 2008 from MossianiteCo.  I see no difference in quality from either ring.

Post # 6
1190 posts
Bumble bee

I bought a 1ct C&C moissanite from Overstock to wear on vacation. I should have checked if it was C&C of but because there was no brilliance and one of the prongs started lifting during our vacation.

I’ve purchased better quality CZ/silver ring from Amazon than what I got.

Post # 7
458 posts
Helper bee

Overstock is like Amazon, Wayfair, (Sears/Walmart) Marketplace, etc. They rely on 3rd party merchants, rather than carrying/creating their own inventory. So, a ring or any other item purchased may not have the same quality as a similar ring/item unless it’s also from the exact same merchant (brand). Search Amazon for the exact ring you’re looking at on Overstock. You might find it for a lower price or find more reviews with pictures.

I’ve bought quite a few cz rings from Overstock, and they’ve been fine. I’ve kicked myself a few times because later found the same ring on Amazon for a better price. My most recent RHR is on Overstock, not in my size, found it on Amazon (not available) and then bought directly from the seller, Szul, at a discount

Post # 8
826 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2018

I don’t personally have experience, but I know someone who bought their engagement ring off overstock.  It was really bad quality in my opinion.  But this was a diamond so it may be different.

Leave a comment

Find Amazing Vendors