Post # 1

Member
208 posts
Helper bee
Hi again everyone!! As I’m sure many of you know by now, i am having quite the bridesmaid dress dilemma!! haha. Someone very nicely (and sooooo intelligently) came up with the idea for me to put a few dresses I am considering in a poll, not tell you guys how much each one is, and let you pick which is your favortie. I’ve included a pic of my dress below too so that might help in any decisions!!
ps. i was thinking we were doing dark navy but lately i have switched to black? What do you all think? So these dresses would either be in dark navy or black, even if they are not those colors in the pics 🙂
#1:
#2:

#3:

#4:

#5:

#6:

MY DRESS :


Post # 3

Member
413 posts
Helper bee
To be honest I only like the first dress. I think it’s inappropiate to have a huge hole in the back of a dress and some of the dresses are REALLY short and look a bit slutty. I really like the pic of the real bride in your dress. Copy what she has done, the satin dresses are classy and elegant and the material goes with the wedding dress really well.
You need to remember your girls aren’t going nightclubbing they are bridesmaids and are attending a wedding..
Post # 4

Member
1014 posts
Bumble bee
Seeing how formal your dress is, I think these choices just aren’t dressy enough. Your dress is so gorgeous and fancy, these dresses just don’t look like they’ll compliment you. I agree with the PP who likes the real bride pic, the long satin dresses look great with your gown.
Post # 5

Member
1297 posts
Bumble bee
- Wedding: February 2017 - Seattle, WA
I picked #1 because it’s the most figure flattering for all body types. The others would be a little hard to pull off on the average body type. That being said, i like that some of the choices are fun, and not the typical bridesmaid dress. If your bridesmaids are comfortable with wearing the more “fun” choices, then I’d say go for it! Have they seen the choices yet? Maybe you should make a poll for them. 🙂 Good luck!
Post # 6

Member
3261 posts
Sugar bee
It’s hard to vote because the choices are all over the place. Its difficult to really tell what look you’re going for…
Post # 7

Member
336 posts
Helper bee
I love dress #2! Where is it from?
Post # 8

Member
4046 posts
Honey bee
#4 will be hard to wear, since it woud be hard to find a bra that would go with that open back.
Post # 9

Member
3978 posts
Honey bee
Post # 10

Member
904 posts
Busy bee
The first one is beautiful.
Post # 11

Member
413 posts
Helper bee
@kala_way: Oh wow I like the one were the model is holding the yellow flowers. Or even the one shoulder number in the middle row.
Post # 12

Member
2742 posts
Sugar bee
@loveyou22: What look are you going for? Some of those dresses seem like they are more ‘party dresses’ than anything. Or is is because I see college and grad school in my back mirror? Maybe it’s just me but most of my friends would not be open with anything other than dress number 1/and or dress number 2 for a Bridesmaid or Best Man dress. OTOH, your dress is gorgeous.
@kala_way: I love the dresses you put up. I think they encompass the first dress on this thread and work with the theme. I’m loving the last dress on the list.
Post # 13

Member
2158 posts
Buzzing bee
I voted number 2. Really, a lot of these dresses you have show wayy too much skin IMO. number one would be nice, but I don’t like the poof
Post # 14

Member
2254 posts
Buzzing bee
I voted #1. With the way the poll is rating, I guess you’ll get your bm dress of choice after all. =)
Post # 15

Member
1987 posts
Buzzing bee
I kindof feel like these dresses are all over the place- I feel like when people suggested the poll they meant a poll of similar dresses.
Sorry if this seems rude.
As for the dresses that were posted by another user- I really really love the last one on the third row.
Post # 16

Member
2947 posts
Sugar bee
Have you looked at Amsale? She has gorgeous floor length gowns that are slightly less than ML. 🙂
If you’re set on short, I love #1 for sure.