Post # 1
We are having a nautical theme and I am pretty sure I will do these as favors, but I wanted to get a sense of which people like better (I have my suspicions!). Also, if anyone thinks this is a lame favor that people won’t like, say so before I decide on them! This place was great, they sent me the fudge/saltwater taffy pail as a free sample. The girl was really nice. Favors for the half bar of fudge/3 piece taffy pail with a little (generic plastic) are only a few cents more than the taffy only pail (10 pieces of taffy). With the # we have to order, the customized ribbons and printing are free, and obviously I can tailor the taffy colors to our theme.
Post # 3
I think taffy only looks better in the pail, but I do like fudge! I guess it depends on what’s more important to you.
Post # 4
@sehrler: It might not count cause I’m in the UK, but I’ve never tasted taffy, so I voted for fudge and taffy to be safe 🙂
Post # 5
Fudge makes me sick, so I voted toffee only.
Post # 6
I voted for the combo. While I really like them both, I know my father and a few other people do not like taffy because it gets stuck to their teeth. A combo, he could eat the fudge and my mom could get the taffy!
Post # 7
If there any way you could do a combination of both? If not I would go with the fudge combo!
Post # 8
@ieatunicorns: do you mean, one bucket of the combo, one bucket of the taffy only? I could do that for couples, at the price they are I’m trying to stay at one favor per person but if they are a couple I could do one of each.
Post # 9
I would prefer the fudge/taffy combo. And I dont know if this is totally crude of me to say, but the way the taffy is packaged looks like a tampon :/
Post # 10
I love these favors! Very nautical-like. I voted for the first one
Post # 11
I voted taffy only but I’m conflicted – I like the look of taffy only, I LOVE saltwater taffy, but I have found (to my surprise) that not everyone likes taffy. So maybe the combo would be better. Also I’d say that 1 per couple would be enough and would save you some money.
Post # 12
I love the first combo! At first glance I thought the all taffy in the pail tookd like tampons- sorry! Maybe because of the white wrapper with the writing, the taffy in the top pic didn’t make me think of that
Post # 13
I think either are awesome, but I chose the taffy only since I’m not big on fudge. I also think the taffy is more “nautical” and don’t feel like fugde really fits into your theme.
Post # 14
I would do the half and half combo. Sounds like a great idea! Can’t go wrong with edible favors!
Post # 15
fudgy fudge and taffy. yummmmmmm fudge