Post # 1
Member
215 posts
Helper bee
We ordered my ring from james allen online and we received it today!!! It is so beautiful!! I love it! But it’s the wrong setting!! I ordered oval pave halo and shank and I received only pave diamonds on the halo with a plain band. When I placed my order I noticed that the item number was not correct so I called and recieved e mail confirmation that it would be the pave halo and shank. I had a feeling things would go wrong because they never charged us for the difference since the setting with pave on the band was a little more.
I’m having doubts if I want to send it back to get the other setting. I kind of feel attached to it now. Also I have heard some people have problems with too many pave diamonds falling out. I’m torn… what do you bee’s think? Send it back for pave on the band and halo?
Post # 2
Member
9793 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
Oooh I love it. I actually covet that exact east west oval halo scenario for a RHR one day! And pave does fall out…
Post # 3
Member
2916 posts
Sugar bee
Keep it, so pretty, was fate!
Post # 4
Member
304 posts
Helper bee
I love it!! But im biased as my ering is also plain shank with halo (not oval) the thing that makes me love it more and more is how beautiful it looks with my half eternity wedding band!!! 
Post # 7
Member
8600 posts
Bumble Beekeeper
I’d keep it and get a blingy band or two for after the wedding.
Post # 8
Member
2934 posts
Sugar bee
babykoala: I think you should keep it. It’s gorgeous.
Post # 9
Member
2934 posts
Sugar bee
Nena16: OMG that might be the prettiest combination of e-ring and wedding band I’ve ever seen. So, so beautiful!
Post # 10
Member
304 posts
Helper bee
Jijitattoo: thank you I adore my rings!
Post # 12
Member
1191 posts
Bumble bee
I think it’s so unique and really pretty!! If you’re attached to it now I really think you’ll miss it when it’s gone. But then again, it would be terrible to always wish you had what you originally ordered. I think it’s truly a beautiful ring though!
Post # 13
Member
2837 posts
Sugar bee
babykoala: I think you’ll feel more comforable day to day with a plain band– if there’s one thing I knew I wanted, it was a plain band– you aren’t constantly worrying that a diamond will fall out and potentially sending it back for repairs. I actually LOVE your rings– and because I appreciate very simple rings (bezel), it’s not often I find other rings I’m in love with!! Keep it, and it a half eternity band!
Post # 14
Member
272 posts
Helper bee
Keep it! Plain shank halos look much more classic in my opinion
Post # 15
Member
5226 posts
Bee Keeper
babykoala: I actually prefer a plain shank with a halo. I think the contrast is beautiful. You are right, I think maintaining pave on the band will end up being a PIA! Stay with the plain shank, it’s fab 
