Post # 1
So Kays has agreed to let me exchange my wedding set for a whole new set because of their shitty repairs and customer service. So here are a few of the ones that caught my eye in the store. If you have a favorite from kays feel free to share!!
Choice 1- Neil Lane
Choice 2- Tolkowsky with an enhancer that would match hubbys ring
Choice 3- Tolkowsky set
Post # 3
@ChellFish22: I think the first one’s beautiful but I can imagine it snagging alot because of the size (If I’m wrong then go for that one it’s beautiful!)
Post # 4
The first one made me go ooh. If snagging would be a problem, then I chage my vote to 2.
Post # 5
I like the centre stone in #1most.
Post # 6
#2, because I love swirly bands and I have a bypass e-ring myself. Plus, bonus points for matching your hubby’s ring!
Post # 7
Love #1 and yay for them letting you exchange!
Post # 8
I have a pear so I’m partial to pears…
Post # 9
I like the first one best, then the second. If you FI really wants you to be matching then maybe that one moves up the charts, as long as you like the gap.
Post # 10
I love the second! Its blingy and has detail. And it would match your husbands! <3
Post # 11
I like the first or the last.
Post # 12
@ChellFish22: I love the look of set #1. It is absolutely stunning!
Post # 13
Oh my, tough choice! They’re all such different styles! I think I have to go with number 1. I have a soft spot for pears! <3
Post # 14
I’m not really crazy about any of them (sorry!) but I found a few that I think are a better size (those first two are a little clunky and the third seems small).
Post # 15
Definitely go with a tolkowski because they’re ideal cut diamonds and the settings tend to hold up a lot better than any Neil Lanes (I work at Kay, people are bringing in their encrusted Neil Lanes with missing diamonds all the time).
But I don’t really like any of the ones you listed. You know you can pick a setting a stone separately? Ask to see the books of settings (Stuller has a ton of them), then pick out a Tolkowski diamond to be set.
And GOOD FOR YOU for demanding excellent service after the repair shop fucks up. I hate it when people post their stories about Kay messing something up. If you go high enough (and you’re within their guidelines and have followed the rules) you DESERVE something that looks nice for the money you spend!!
Here is the stuller website, which has everything the book has: http://www.stuller.com/browse/wedding-and-engagement/engagements
Post # 16
Not a fan of all three but if I had to pick one, I’d go with two. I really don’t like the first one. The halos are just too bulky and it kinda makes it look too “costume-y” in my eyes.