Post # 1
So, I am ordering a plain band to go with my set and that I can wear all the time no matter what. I don’t ever wear my rings anymore because of work, and I want something I can always have on. I don’t want white gold because white gold and I do not agree. I always have to have it replaTed every month or so because it just turns yellow and looks weird. So, 18k rose or yellow it is! I love rose gold, I think the color is so pretty, but I worry that it is just trendy and I may hate it one day, whereas yellow gold is always gorgeous. What would your choice be? Please share any pictures of your mismatched sets or yellow or rose gold rings!! And for reference these are the two I am deciding between.
Post # 2
I LOVE rose gold but I think it looks better in small doses. With this style, it might be a bit too pink for my tastes. I would go with yellow gold. Also, I don’t think you’ll regret yellow gold, whereas, as you said, rose gold might get old after a while. That’s just personal preference; you can’t go wrong either way. Both are beautiful!!
Post # 3
I love the rose! I also wouldn’t call it “trendy” as much as just popular. Saying it’s a trend makes it sound like it won’t always be around. All 3 metals have been around for forever
, so they are all classic.
Post # 4
Based on those pictures I would want to go for the yellow gold, I agree with you that the rose gold looks very pink but that might just be the pic. I love rose gold but I love rose gold on other people (it just looks weird on my skin tone). Just choose whatever you like! I agree that rose gold is becoming more popular, but if you love it you love it. At the end of the day get what makes you happy, even if it is popular.
Post # 5
I like the yellow gold better.
Post # 6
I love rose gold!! But it really depends on your skin tone, rose gold doesn’t work on everyone where as yellow gold is more universally flattering.
Post # 7
The yellow is perfect! The rose looks too pink IMO
Post # 8
That’s beautiful! I vote rose gold.
Where are you ordering this from?
Post # 9
Pretty, pretty ring design. It is so lovely and graceful. I love rose gold, and think it’s so pretty. But, based on the pictures you posted, I like this band best in the yellow gold. What metal color is the rest of your set? I have both a rose and a yellow gold band that I sometimes wear with my platinum ring. I like the look of the different metals together.
Post # 10
The yellow looks better to me in this style
Post # 11
I don’t like yellow gold but I agree that in this style it might be best. I think it really depends on your skin tone thouh, I chose a rose gold band and I don’t think I’ll ever grow tired of it because it looks really REALLy nice on my skin tone; better than yellow and white. I just say go with what looks best.
Post # 12
I voted yellow, I think it suits this style better. For what it’s worth, I had a jeweler tell me that rose gold isn’t always the best option because the copper can wear out/off and you’ll just be left with yellow gold anyway. I don’t think this guy had an agenda in telling me this, as I was just asking questions and not actually shopping, but take this advice with a grain of salt.
Post # 13
I normally have a strong preference of rose gold over yellow gold, but I agree with the previous posters, the yellow gold suits this ring more, in my opinion! 🙂
Post # 14
I think it’s prettier in the YG.
Post # 15
I adore rosse gold, but I also think it works with my skin tone a lot better, yellow gold makes me look a bit green. Maybe see which looks nicer on your hand. Or you could buy both hehe!!!