(Closed) rustic unique venue for nj or ny? HELP!!!

posted 9 years ago in New Jersey – North Central New Jersey
Post # 4
132 posts
Blushing bee

@lmeenol:  we were looking for the same thing and just booked Perona Farms! They have a barn which they are currently restoring into a reception venue… It should be done next month. There are not photos on the website of the inside of the barn because its not yet completed. We fell in love and booked on the spot!! first place we looked!

Post # 5
6 posts
  • Wedding: May 2013

Have you considered Brooklyn NY? There are a few places that are beautiful. Dumbo loft, My Moon…

Post # 6
16 posts
  • Wedding: March 2015

You might want to check out Prallsville Mills in Stockton (on the PA border, not far from Princeton)-there is a site fee (i’ve read it’s tax deductible because it’s a donation to the society that manages the site – not sure, just throwing it out there) – you’ll have to bring in a caterer and all, but it has a nice look: http://erinhphotography.com/blog/katiedevon/

Check out local women’s clubs, too – the Women’s Club of Englewood looks nice – but I think it’s small. Warwick, NY has some nice wineries.

Post # 8
160 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: October 2012

We had our wedding at Highlands Country Club (Garrison, NY near Bear Mountain).  Rustic old building with fireplaces and very vintage feel, not your typical country club at all.  They do not allow caterers there but the food is AMAZING… better than any restaurant i;ve been to, people from my wedding are still raving about the food.  Check it out. 


Post # 9
132 posts
Blushing bee

View original reply
@lmeenol:  awesome! I did too ๐Ÿ™‚ cat wait to see it finished. When we booked it was completely gutted. It’s killing me that I can’t start planning decorations etc bc idk what the final place will look like. When you booked had they decided on reception seating? Curious if they went w long tables or the more typical circle tables! 

Post # 12
11 posts

Depending on your budget, there are several wineries to consider. If you want to bring in your own catering though, take a look at Alba Vineyards. Other wineries would be Unionville and Tomasello, both of which are rustic and beautiful. Good luck!

Post # 13
103 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: September 2013

We booked at Lake Valhalla Club. It’s definitely not your traditional gaudy banquet hall. The room has these two gorgeous fireplaces on either side. The ceremony space is just beautiful overlooking the lake.


honestly the pictures don’t do it justice.

I wish i didn’t have to have a church wedding, otherwise I would LOVE to have my ceremony there too.

They don’t allow outside caterers, but they do make everything fresh which is good. (No frozen appetizers) During the hurricane when they lost power for example they didnt have any issues and threw 3 weddings without any issues.


Good luck!!!!

Post # 14
418 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: July 2013

Sayen Gardens in Hamilton.  It’s where we’re having out rustic/vintage inspired wedding.  Our ceremony will be in a garden gazebo and the reception will be in the old house, which is decorated really quirky with antiques and little knick knacks.  FI and I wanted something non-traditional (like us) and the second we walked in this place that was it!  

The down side is that there is only room for roughly 100 guests.  I think they say 115 max but I think that would be too much.  Also, you have the option to choose from 4 caterers.  For a yummy and creative menu I’d go with Emily’s Cafe.. We loved them but they were too expensive for us ๐Ÿ™

The topic ‘rustic unique venue for nj or ny? HELP!!!’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors