Post # 1
Member
7 posts
Newbee
So I hate shoe shopping in general, so finding wedding shoes is turning out to be buckets of fun. I have some styles narrowed down and was hoping to bounce my ideas around here. I would love feedback, especially if you have experience with any of these companies/styles.
My first thought was a short heel (I cannot do tall heels – I’m a klutz in them, and my fiance is not that much taller than me.)
There’s Culver by Nina
and also Criana by Nina
I like that they both have reviews for being comfortable, and that they’re both on Zappos (don’t have to worry about paying for returns, plus I have a giftcard = free wedding shoes). Also they re available in navy blue, which will be the color of my Bridesmaid or Best Man dresses.
I also thought about maybe a low wedge, since they’re a little bit nice than a flat. I found Anette by Dyables.
Not as many reviews overall, and some that say they’re uncomfortable, but with free returns it might be worth a try.
David’s Bridal also has some dyeable low wedges, but I’m a bit stuck on the Zappos thing.
If you have any advie (which I hope you do!), please keep the following in mind:
I can’t do high heels – 2.5″ at the ABSOLUTE most.
Comfort is key – I’m not buying pretty shoes so that I can wear them for ceremony and photos then changing into flats or flip flops.
Dark blue or dyeable is preferred, but not necessary.
Zappos = free shoes for me.
Ready, set, go! 
Post # 3
Member
1420 posts
Bumble bee
- Wedding: September 2014 - Turf Valley
I love those Criana by Nina shoes! I am not a fan of wedges, personally. I just don’t think they add that “sexy” that I like. I personally would go for the Criana shoes since they’re A) Free, B) Low heel, and C) Rated comfortable!
Post # 4
Member
1231 posts
Bumble bee
Seems like Zappos shoe is the better choice (free, comfortable, good reviews, navy blue). Plus, I like heels (even low heels) better than wedges. If I had to choose between the top 2 shoes, I would pick #1. Just my opinion!
Good luck!
Post # 5
Member
2532 posts
Sugar bee
Why not just wear flats?
TOMS are plenty comfy, I had a friend who wore them on her wedding day and absolutely loved them.
Whatever you do, make sure you break in the heels so they’re comfy.
A few pairs of damp clean socks (I know, eww) on your feet and then in the shoe for a few hours helps a ton!
Post # 6
Member
164 posts
Blushing bee
@MeredithLee11: I bought the 2nd pair (Nina Criana) as my wedding shoes for next summer. I ordered them from Zappos, and they were actually the third pair of wedding shoes I ordered from them. It was very convenient to send back and return the shoes that didn’t work out. I printed out a prepaid UPS label, dropped them off at the UPS store, and that was that.
I tried the Nina Culver shoes, and while the heel height was comfortable (I can’t walk in high heels either!), I didn’t like the D’orsay cutout at the arch of the foot. I felt unsteady in the shoes. I’ve practiced walking around in the Criana shoes, and I think they are pretty comfortable as far as dress shoes go, and the heel height is definitely manageable! I like that there is more “coverage” for my foot, so I feel more steady. I’m not worried about tripping or falling on my wedding day because my feet are sliding around in my shoes, lol. I ordered the Nina Criana shoes in the dark purple color and plan to add fancy shoe clips to bling them out a bit more!
Post # 7
Member
49 posts
Newbee
I also am not a big heel person. Just wearing my heels for my dress fittings were torture after a while, and mine are 2 and 1/2 inch, haha. I’ll wear them for the ceremony but for the party I’ll be changing into these. They’re about same height as my shoes and with my dress you honestly can’t even see them. I feel like this is my best wedding investment, cuz I plan to dance! LOL. They’re from famousfootwear.com. As for your shoe selections above, the first ones are my fave. Good luck!
Post # 8
Member
1841 posts
Buzzing bee
I think I like the Criana a bit better. They look rather comfortable. I’d jazz them up with low-cost shoe clips from Etsy.
I’m wearing Nina in dark blue:
