(Closed) Should I go pick the stone with him? Advice please!

posted 9 years ago in Rings
Post # 3
238 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: January 2011

I would, and did, but then I’m nosey Laughing

Post # 4
722 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2014

Is there any way you can go along, give your two cents about a the handful of rings you like and then leave while he makes up his mind, that way preserving both the control and the surprise element? That is unless you fall in love with just one ring!

Post # 5
426 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: September 2012

I think this is a very personal choice. I went with my SO to pick out my e-ring. We both were just going to look so he could get an idea of what I like, other than what I had already showed him online. I was afraid he would get something with too much bling on it, I wanted something really simple and no too expensive. When we went to look at e-rings I completely fell in love with one that I tried on. So we got it. He picked it up and gave it to me. We were already engaged before I had an e-ring anyways so I guess it didn’t seem like a big deal to us. Also he showed me a ring he would have gotten and while it was nice, it also was very blingy three stone diamond ring with tiny diamonds all around the band. I don’t know if I described it well, but it was not something I think I would have been comfortable wearing. 

Just think about what is more important to you. Having your SO pick out your ring for you or being very active picking out your own ring?

Post # 6
76 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: October 2012

My Fiance did everything himself.  Of course we had talked about it, and I had emailed him some rings I liked.  But, in the end he did it himself.  Honestly, I would have NEVER picked this one, but it’s perfect! My vote is to let him do it himself.  I love to be in control, but not being in control of this one thing was absoutely perfect for us. He knows me better than I know myself sometimes, and this was one of those times.

Post # 7
1 posts
  • Wedding: June 2013

I agree with @xicaB that it is such a personal choice. We had such a great time choosing the ring together…it was an experience I was glad to be a part of. Since for us it was the first step in getting married, it felt so great to share it together. Also, I was still surprised when he proposed– and the ring looks a million times better when it is officially yours:)

Post # 8
515 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: March 2014

I’m a type A planner — in some ways it is sad that the suprise element isn’t there (to an extent, though I’m picking out my own ring, BF will decide how, where, and when to acutally ask) but am incredibly pleased that I get to pick my ring so I know it will be something I will love forever…

If you want to keep some surprise, pick a couple and then leave and let your BF handle the rest…

Post # 10
3828 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: January 1998

YES go…if he asked then he might want you there

Post # 11
9168 posts
Buzzing Beekeeper
  • Wedding: November 1999

I would definitely go! Then again, I knew every detail about what was happening with my ring but my Fiance still managed to completely surprise me!

Post # 12
622 posts
Busy bee

I would go. I think if you do go, you will be able to sleep well at night knowing you covered all the bases you wanted to. Plus, I LOVED going ring shopping with my Fiance, and I think you will have a lot of fun doing it together! 🙂

Post # 13
232 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: September 2012

I picked mine and he picked his.

Post # 14
2015 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: May 2012

I would go along for at least one meeting so that he can get a very specific idea of what you’d like (and the jeweler can, too), and then let him pick the stone himself. Perhaps even narrow it down to a handful of stones, then let him take over from there.

Personally, I thought I had told my fiance exactly what I wanted, but it got completely misinterpreted when he met with the diamond wholesaler. A lot of men (and, actually, people in general) have a tendancy to grab onto one word or phrase and not really see the big picture of what you want. Particularly if you’re type A, I think it would put you both at ease to give input on specific stones, even if you don’t ultimately make the final decision.

Post # 15
2503 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: June 2012

I went with my Fiance and picked out everything – setting, the exact stone, etc. We are both very particular people and I’m pretty sure he was glad I was there to pick it out to make sure that I 100% loved it. My is a handset custom ring, so while I saw the setting in store (with a lower quality diamond), I never saw it with my diamond in it, so that part was still a surprise. It totally suits our relationship and works for us and I think it would’ve been a lot of pressure on his end to go into this blind. In addition, I have a fancy cut (versus a round) so you really have to see it in person, rather than going off of numbers. For example, I could tell him I want 1.2 carats, F, VS1 and whatever, but just those specs alone could yield widely different diamonds when it comes to fancy cuts.

It is difficult to go in and pick out the stone with him though, if you don’t want to know his budget. I mean, the best case scenario would be that all the ones you love are below his budget. The worst case would be if you love all the ones that are in the higher range of his budget, or too expensive for him altogether. I knew FI’s budget going into this, and it was helpful in setting both of our expectations. I actually came in on the lower-middle range of what Fiance was expecting.

Post # 16
2812 posts
Sugar bee

We both picked our rings so I would say yes. 

The topic ‘Should I go pick the stone with him? Advice please!’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors