Post # 1
Member
83 posts
Worker bee
I know I am very indecisive but I just cannot seem to make up my mind. 🙂 I want to get a replacement engagement ring for the one I lost years ago by this November for our 10th anniversary. We are very limited in budget. I have a sapphire we bought, but honestly I am so up in the air right now about it. I also have a blue Zircon which I love but I know it is a softer stone and have to think about that in every day wear. My other option would be to get a swiss blue topaz. At least the blue topaz is cheaper to replace. I am at home most the time and would take my ring off before housework or showering. i would appreciate some help in deciding.
Here is my sapphire
Here is my zircon
I am open to all suggestions and appreciate any feedback. Thank you so much in advance. oh and sorry if the pics are too big. I am doing this on my phone.
Post # 4
Member
271 posts
Helper bee
Why are you up in the air about the sapphire? I think it’s a beautiful stone, and I really love that cut.
Post # 5
Member
1768 posts
Buzzing bee
@MyrtletheTurtle: definitey the sapphire. No question.
Post # 6
Member
83 posts
Worker bee
@lilcafe: Thank you!
@missmess: Well I like the sapphire, but that pic was taken directly under the light in our room. The stone darkens up a lot, and part of me wants a bluer stone . Thank you
Post # 7
Member
83 posts
Worker bee
@gemgirl6: So you like the sapphire too. I appreciate the feedback. Maybe I am just being picky.
Post # 8
Member
2496 posts
Buzzing bee
@MyrtletheTurtle: Definitely the sapphire.
Post # 9
Member
83 posts
Worker bee
@somethingaquamarine: Thank you. So far there seems to be a consensus
Post # 10
Member
561 posts
Busy bee
I vote Sapphire. It will be beautiful!
Post # 12
Member
11265 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
@MyrtletheTurtle: i love the sapphire and i really love the colour of that zircon. very vibrant. they are both very different. pick the one that suits your personality. they are both beautiful.
Post # 13
Member
2733 posts
Sugar bee
I would do your beautiful blue sapphire or a lab-made sapphire to remake your ring. Sapphires are the strongest stones among your options, and so beautiful. White sapphires do look oily and dirty easily. I have a white sapphire ring and I like the particular sparkle and appearance, but it clouds up faster than my diamond ring. I just clean it, but it’s something to think about 😉
Post # 14
Member
213 posts
Helper bee
I love the sapphire.. The cut and the color is so pretty..
If you want lighter blue, why not get another sapphire? The lighter blue is usually cheaper than the deep color.
Post # 15
Member
330 posts
Helper bee
The blue sapphire….pleeeeease! Love that color & cut, and it seems like a nice size too. What is the mm size & carat weight, if you don’t mind my asking?
Post # 16
Member
444 posts
Helper bee
From what I see in the photos, the zircon looks more beautiful to me. Yes it’s a softer stone but perhaps put it in a bezel setting and be ok with the fact that you may have to replace it down the line/wear it less often. I do love sapphires, but the lighter blue of that zircon is so pretty.
