(Closed) Speaking up about red flags in a family member's relationship?

posted 3 years ago in Family
Post # 16
2811 posts
Sugar bee

I would totally stay out of it. It doesn’t concern you. MYOB.

Post # 19
632 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: August 2015

As someone who’s been on the receiving end of religion-related drama from my parents when I was planning my wedding… maybe this part isn’t as it seems to you. It’s possible that your SIL’s Fiance feels very strongly that religious counseling is not right for him, and your SIL doesn’t have a strong opinion on this so she’s going along with him. They’re the ones who would be in counseling, not her parents, so while maybe the parents should insist on counseling, the couple should choose where. 

For what it’s worth, in our case Darling Husband was very strongly against a religious ceremony because he’s deeply spiritual. It might sound like a paradox, but he said that we are not following many religious ceremonies in our daily life, so it doesn’t feel right to him to adopt the trappings on our wedding day, and he would not want to project a more religious image until he feels that he walks the walk every day, not just talks the talk. I wanted to do the traditional thing, but was impressed by his argument and we together told my parents that sorry, no slight intended, but we would have a secular ceremony.

Now if he’s showing a volatile temper, that’s a different story… that’s a red flag all right and something you or your husband should bring up with your SIL. Hopefully in a way that doesn’t make her defensive, but I imagine that’s not easy! And that comes back to counseling being a very good idea.

Post # 20
2710 posts
Sugar bee

I would possibly say something about the temper, but not the church wedding side of things. That doesn’t say red-flag to me at all. Many people stay connected to the church out of duty, tradition, and community without really connecting with the faith. The counselling on the other hand forces him to really participate in his spirituality. If he doesn’t actually see himself as a spritual person, then it’s forcing a faith on him that isn’t his. It doesn’t surprise me that he might agree to a church wedding, but refuse spritual counselling if he doesn’t see himself as spritual.


Would they consider secular counselling? My parents suggested it for my Fi and I and he balked in much the same way – seeing counselling as being lectured and told you’re flawed, rather than as something that can help you grow and be really clear about your goals as a couple. My Fiance came around once I explained that was more the case, it’s about talking through things yourself and being focused, not being told what to do and how to do it. In fact counsellors can’t actually tell you what you should or shouldn’t do.


The temper red flags on the other hand are a bit different – but I know you have already decided not to bring that up. Chalking a bad temper up to immaturity is never very wise.. not if they’re unwilling to work on themselves as it seems he is. Having a bad temper doesn’t always lead to abuse, but even on its own it can be difficult to deal with. Watch for the warning signs, stay close to your SIL and show her that you will always be there for her.

Post # 21
901 posts
Busy bee

View original reply
LadyJDAG :  I really hope your husband has spoken to his sister about his concern. Concern coming from a sibling has a different slant than coming from a parent. I would want my brother to definitely say something if he saw me in a concerning situation. Right now, the parents seem to be in controlling mode. Therefore, concern from brother would likely be viewd as less biased than parental concern.

Post # 22
337 posts
Helper bee

View original reply
LadyJDAG :  Well…this was me. I was that girl… my ex was a lot like him, hot temper, immature, short sighted, no intellectual curiosity etc. I also just really wanted the wedding, I was SO excited to be a bride and get the wedding dress.

However, from my experience, I KNEW inside that it was bad, had bad feelings, but due to codepency I overlooked things and rationalized them and ignored… It’s hard to try and get someone in that position to see the truth. People tried to tell me, and while I didn’t get mad at them or anything, but I couldn’t hear it. It’s possible she’s being mentally or emotionally abused (maybe not, but I was) and it might be that she has to see it for herself.

Depending on your relationship with her, you could go out to coffee and mention things… in a way of asking if she’s happy, if she loves him… that was a kicker for me. I could pretend but the worst is when someone asked why I loved him… because I had no reasons. I “loved” him because he “loved” me so much. Ugh. I hope she gets out of that situation and realizes she deserves more! If you talk with her do it nicely and kindly, while accepting her no matter what she does, that’s incredibly important. 

Post # 26
7595 posts
Bumble Beekeeper

View original reply
LadyJDAG :  This guy sounds a lot like my ex. He was also arrogant AF and could twist any situation to make himself the victim because the idea of admitting fault in any degree was just unthinkable to him. He definitely lacked humility, and I totally agree with you that humility is a key ingredient in a healthy relationship. Both parties have to be wililng to admit fault sometimes, and to put the other person’s desires above their own from time to time. Without humility, the idea of prioritizing what your partner wants over what you want (when there’s a conflict between the two, which is inevitable in any partnership) is unthinkable.

What drew me to this asshole in the first place was, ironically, the very qualities that made him such a horrible boyfriend. He was extremely charismatic, the life of the party, and it was just exciting to be with him. He seemed so confident…he could walk into a room and just set the mood instantly, depending on his own personal mood at that moment. I am not a very controlling person and I liked being with someone who was so dominant and seemed to just know what to do at all times. I also liked that other people seemed impressed by him and craved his company…it’s pathetic, but my vanity was flattered that this charismatic life of the party guy had picked me as his partner.

Once the initial honeymoon wore off though, it was 2.5 yrs of increasing agony being with him. He wasn’t there for me at all. He let me down so many times, in small ways and big ones. He had no respect for my family. He always put himself first every single time. And he had no capacity for self reflection. Any time I even tried to tell him why x behavior of his was hurtful, he would immediately twist it around and make himself the victim. “You’re always mad at me, I guess you think I’m a bad boyfriend,” etc. And then before I knew it, I’d be the one apologizing to HIM! It was masterful.

Anyway …if any of this is ringing true, I def think you should proceed with your plan to have your brother talk to her. it needs to be done very carefully and gently. I wish more people had told me what they really thought of my ex…but they didn’t want to offend me, and I also didn’t tell anyone most of the horrors that happened between closed doors, so people just didn’t know. My parents never liked him, but they never liked any of my boyfriends lol so that wasn’t an immediate red flag. But I think if someone I trusted as a nonbiased party had spoken to me honestly about their concerns, it would have had an effect. Maybe it would have made me break up with him earlier, idk. So yeah, I hope you’re able to get through to her. But if you’re not…that’s ok too. She has to make her own choices, which might mean learning this lesson the hard way.

Post # 27
1908 posts
Buzzing bee
  • Wedding: February 2015

This is what I’ve learned from adulting, don’t offer advice that isn’t requested.

The topic ‘Speaking up about red flags in a family member's relationship?’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors