(Closed) St Thomas vs. Grand Cayman for Honeymoon

posted 9 years ago in Honeymoons
Post # 3
184 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: October 2010

Congrats for being to take such an awesome honeymoon!!

I have been to both islands. here are my opinions-

Grand Cayman- I LOVE IT. The Ritz there is incredible. I didn’t stay there (I think I stayed at the comfort suites, this was 3 years ago) but we had lunch at the ritz one day and it is gorgeous. I would either rent a car, or see if you can get a driver from the hotel to get around the island. The beach at the hotel is nice, but there are better beaches (some of the best i have ever seen!) that are not around the hotels. Cemetery beach is one of them- a lonnnggggg strech of goregous, unspoiled, secluded beach. There are coral reefs everywhere, and you could swim out a long way. All the beaches are public, so you can go anywhere. The locals are very friendly, and everything is safe. There are a number of great restuarants around the island. There was one in particular, I can’t remember the name but I will try to research it for you, which is located in a bird sanctuary, it is open-air with incredible birds and plants etc. around, and the food was incredible. All the food I had everywhere was iwonderful there is a nother restuarant at the other end of the island from the ritz, it had something to do with a lighhouse- I really need to look these up for you- and that was INCREDIBLE (I have used that word so many times!). I bet if you say it is your honeymoon they could give you one of the best tables at the end of the dock. That place was pretty fancy as far as island dining goes. The island is really breath-taking, the reefs are plentiful and beautiful, I loved it! It is also a small island so you will feel like you saw most of it. I would also recommend getting a private boat tour thing of some other reefs and sting ray city since you mentioned liking to snorkel, to do some snorkeling off the shore. (sting ray city is a must).

St. Thomas- I was not there for that long, I flew in and then spent a week on st. john 2 years ago. The idea i got of st. thomas is that it was more metropolitan then st. john. I don’t think that the beaches are as good at grand cayman, and it is more focused on nightlife then both grand cayman and st. john. BUT, you could do a number of day trips- I went to the BVIs for example, and those are tons of fun. The ritz on st. thomas is supposed to be really wonderful, but i feel that the island is more "exciting" and lively then grand cayman, which might not be what you are looking for. Plus, the snorkeling at grand cayman is definately better. 

I hope this helps, I bet you can tell I am bias, but either would be a memorable trip! Let me know if you want me to figure out the restuarant names! There are really incredible places to eat on grand cayman.  Good luck choosing!


Post # 4
3526 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: August 2010

I’ve been to both as well and my opinion is actually the exact opposite of LisaBee.

We were in Grand Cayman about three years ago, the island IS beautiful. Lots of shopping to be had -but I felt very touristy- and I didn’t really feel safe walking away from the main ports. However, if you are into scuba diving it has some of the best scuba diving in North America according to The Travel Channel. There’s also snorkeling and ship diving to be had! My opinion is that the island was pretty pricey compared to St. Thomas.

I LOVE St. Thomas, when we were first thinking of island destination wedding St. Thomas was where we wanted it. Some of the most crystal clear water I have ever seen in my life. The islands I thought were beautiful way nicer than the ones I went to in Grand Caymen.The pristine sand where crystal white the water crystal clear with tropical fishes swimming around your feet. There is also some good shopping to be had!

P.S. As a side note if you are into jewlery save some money up! The gold/diamond/stones in the Cayman are the best in the world and the prices are to die for!

Good Luck! I think both are beautiful and would be wonderful. 



Post # 7
7052 posts
Busy Beekeeper
  • Wedding: July 2010

I’ve walked near the Ritz in Grand Cayman and love Grand Cayman.

I cannot fairly say which island to visit, since the other island is on my list of "to go" places, but yet haven’t made it there so far.

Seriously..the brand is so consistent you probably can’t go wrong either way! T love and adores St. Thomas.  We’ve been talking of taking a vacay to the Virgin Islands..he swears it’s so naturally gorgeous.

Cayman is fairly flat.  But there are many interesting things to do, water clarity is amazing if you dive or snorkel, and the friendly stingrays are something to see and interact with.  Plus there’s this lizard (think it’s an iguana) on the endangered species list there that’s cute..

Post # 8
961 posts
Busy bee

We are going to Grand Cayman and staying at the Ritz!!!

I am sooooo incredibly excited.  My FH’s business partner is giving us the trip as a wedding gift (he says: "instead of some horribly expensive crystal vase that we’ll never use!")

I feel so blessed.  We weren’t even going to take a honeymoon until next year (to Bora Bora) because we’re spending so much on our small wedding at a winery (the budget miracously doubled!) and renovating his house. 

The topic ‘St Thomas vs. Grand Cayman for Honeymoon’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors