Post # 1
Member
286 posts
Helper bee
Help Bees!! For a very long time I have wanted a platinum engagement ring. I have done some further research and I’m now not sure platinum is for me. I worry about the patina and dark grey metal as opposed to whiter metal of white gold (I think I want a solitaire). I’m not interested in redipping white gold. Palladium is out of the question as not many jewellers in Australia would touch it and I want any jeweller to be able to fix my ring if it ever needed anything.
HOWEVER! I did read that rose gold doesn’t need redipping ever, like yellow gold. Soooo what are all of your opinions on rose gold? Do you love it? Hate it? Is it too trendy? Not classic enough to look like a real engagement ring? Honest opinions are welcome 🙂 I don’t think I’ve ever owned rose gold Jewellery before so it might not suit my skin type at all. I kind of like the warmth of rose gold over the cool of platinum/white gold, however I’m not sure if I’m just in a rose gold phase at the moment which may pass. FYI I like 14k and 10k rose gold and I like plain wedding bands.
So bees, do what you do best and show me your rings!!! And share your opinions on my rose gold dilemma! I have added a poll for extra enjoyment 🙂
Post # 3
Member
2554 posts
Sugar bee
I reallly love rose gold!!!! And, one thing about white gold, if you would like it to be a little warmer, dont get it dipped. I’ve never had my white gold e-ring dipped (I’ve had it 2+years) and the color is pretty, just a little warmer than regular. I dont plan to ever get them dipped for as long as I have them.
Post # 4
Member
7494 posts
Busy Beekeeper
I’m not a fan of rose gold for wedding jewelry. I think it’s too trendy, and it only looks good on certain skin tones. If you’re doing white stones, I personally only like white in white. I also don’t like platinum because of the patina. White gold was the clear choice for me.
Post # 5
Member
1427 posts
Bumble bee
- Wedding: June 2010 - parent's backyard
there are different kinds of white gold, they’re not all made with the same alloys. some are yellower than others. if you get the right kind, it does not need to be redipped. my rings are white gold and they are only just the slightest bit yellow. it’s only noticeable if I hold it up against my sterling silver rings. on it’s own, it looks white.
honestly, I’d reconsider palladium if I were you. you really only need to find one good jeweler. you will feel more comfortalbe going back to the same person, and it’s not like you are going to have to do it that often. I have one jeweler that I trust and I will keep going back to her until I move away.
Post # 6
Member
1199 posts
Bumble bee
@hidingpearl: my shank is 14k rose gold:) I think rose gold is just so romantic! looks great with white metals if yoi want a mixed metal stack. I’ve never seen 10k rose gold, but I imagine it looks more pink than mine.
Post # 7
Member
2554 posts
Sugar bee
AND, I have my eye on a ring like this one as a RHR…so so pretty. I saw it somewhere on the bee and pinned it, but no clue where it came from.
Post # 8
Member
53 posts
Worker bee
I have a white gold e ring and a rose gold wedding band. I take my engagement ring off to sleep and shower, but once I’m married, I don’t plan on ever taking my wedding band off. I didn’t want to have to send it out to be redipped. And I love love love how it looks.
I also have a mixed metal set that I wear every day on my right hand, so mixed metals in my wedding set kind of “matches” my other hand. I have 2 sisters, and we all have the same stack. We call them our sister rings- they’re white, yellow, and rose gold, one gold for each sister.
I just think you can’t go wrong with mixed metals. It makes it reallly easy to wear whatever other jewelry you want, without worrying about matching. if you always wanted platinum, maybe you could stick with platinum for your e-ring and go for rose gold for your wedding band? Or vice versa? No matter what you choose, I’m sure it will be gorgeous!
Post # 9
Member
663 posts
Busy bee
I have always loved rose gold and do not regret my e-ring choice as trendy. I love my recently purchased wedding band in rose gold, too. My set is in 14k. Not sure about the “skin tone” issue….I am pale like Casper the Ghost and I love how the rose gold looks on my hand. I’ve included a picture of the set in warm light.
Post # 10
Member
5507 posts
Bee Keeper
@hidingpearl: I like rose gold on others but when I set my stone it ended up not looking great on me. You really have to go try it on before you decide. Here’s my pic anyway.
Post # 11
Member
5507 posts
Bee Keeper
@Micheruby: we are gonna need pics 😉
Post # 12
Hostess
11334 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
@hidingpearl: I love rose gold so I’ve commented to talk you in to it.
Post # 13
Member
1121 posts
Bumble bee
I only like rose gold for a solitaire & On tan or olive skin tones.
Post # 14
Member
16 posts
Newbee
My mother and grandmother have rose gold jewelry, and my parents have rose gold wedding bands. Granted, they’re from eastern Europe, so there’s variation across cultures, but to me, rose gold is classic and timeless, not to mention flattering and romantic. I love it!
Post # 15
Member
892 posts
Busy bee
I have rose gold and I love it! I always knew I wanted a rose gold ring. Mine is 14k.
Things are only trendy for an individual when you stop liking it eventually. I know I will never stop loving my rose gold 🙂
Post # 16
Member
53 posts
Worker bee
@wrkbrk: I don’t have the wedding band yet and fi hid it somewhere in the house so I can’t show you that one- haha. But here are the sister rings- yay for mixed metals!
