Post # 16

Member
33 posts
Newbee
nfran : Oh dear, I’m so sorry to hear that. My mom reminded me that my aunt’s sister died tragically on her birthday, so that day would have been a mess of emotions for her. I decided it was best to just avoid it.
Post # 17

Member
552 posts
Busy bee
No I’d say that to your face. An 80th birthday might be the last milestone she gets. If you’re cool with that, you do you. But your fixation on a specific date becaue it’s “cool” is bridezilla-ish.
Post # 18

Member
33 posts
Newbee
alex313 : Wow, okay. The judgments are flying. In fact, I usually need to be reminded to think of myself more, so your judgments don’t represent facts about me. Moreover, if you had read my update post, you’d see that we set the date for the day before. Ultimately I could not justify setting the date on her day. We will still have her cake and dance to celebrate her given that her birthday is the next day.
Post # 19

Member
10487 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
I wouldn’t purposely scheduled on someone’s birthday. It puts the family in the weird position of deciding which thing to celebrate and feelings will get hurt some where for someone.
Post # 20

Member
251 posts
Helper bee
annalisarose : I’m in the minority here, but I don’t really see the big deal of having a wedding the same day as a birthday, milestone or not. If that person and their family would rather celebrate the birthday and skip the wedding, that’s their choice, as long as you’re ok with the possibility of people declining if they already have something planned. A cousin of mine had their wedding on my 21st birthday. I almost didn’t go so I could stay home and celebrate by going out with friends, but I ended up going and I had an awesome time since I was legally able to drink. No one made mention of my birthday (except for my immediate family of course), but they didn’t make an announcement or anything and I was fine.. I went out the following weekend with my friends and had a blast then as well. Weddings aren’t the only celebrations that can be moved. I almost never celebrate my birthday on the actual day. Life happens, people are busy. If that date is really that important to you (for whatever reason, don’t feel like you have to justify why it’s important to you), then have it that day. If your aunt declines, be graceful about it, and enjoy your wedding!
ETA: if you move your wedding date because of one guests birthday, it’s only fair to make sure you’re not making the new date on someone else’s birthday and to me, it wouldn’t be worth all that trouble. Someone is always going to have a scheduling conflict and won’t be able to make it. You can’t make everyone happy, so have the wedding when you want it. If you do, maybe make an announcement about your aunts birthday. It would take less than 5 minutes, and I think that would keep everyone happy.
Post # 21

Member
251 posts
Helper bee
I just read through your updates and saw that you went with your original date! Good for you! Funny thing is, 11/16 is actually MY birthday!! Haha so enjoy it! It’s a good day! 😉😜
Post # 22

Member
3233 posts
Sugar bee
I feel like it was her birthday first. Have your wedding the following weekend.
Post # 23

Member
8400 posts
Bumble Beekeeper
If you invite 200+ people, its incredibly likely that someone has a birthday that day or close to it. You can’t change things for everyone. I don’t think this is an issue personally.
Post # 24

Member
33 posts
Newbee
ashley.nicole.2122 : Haha wow, coincidental! Yeah, it just wasn’t sitting well with me. If her daughters (my first cousins) knowingly scheduled a big event on MY mother’s 70th, I’d be really upset. Granted, they have a long history of very selfish behavior which I do not, but that’s irrelevant 🙂. This way, I’m actually giving her a gift: my wedding will hopefully force her kids, who frequently flake on her and my uncle, to gather all in one place. They never really get that, sadly.
Post # 25

Member
528 posts
Busy bee
annalisarose : I think it wasn’t clear from your other update that you changed the date to the day BEFORE your aunt’s birthday (so 11/16 instead of 11/17). That’s why it initially sounded like you decided to go along with your plan anyway and keep it on the same day.
Having it ON her milestone birthday (assuming you’re close to her) would have been super inconsiderate. But I think this way is absolutely fine. Plus, now she’ll have all the family over together to celebrate with her the next day.
Post # 26

Member
33 posts
Newbee
slothbear : I looked back at my update and I can see where it would have been unclear. I feel like having it on 11/17, which is her bday, would hurt them and possibly cause them not to come. It’s just easier to have it the day before so Fiance and I get our favorite time of year and she gets her own day.