Post # 1
I just got engaged yesterday (Memorial Day).
My fiance’s birthday is next week, and all he has been talking about is how he wants ice cream cake from Friendly’s…So I thought I’d be domestic and me & my grandmother made him a homemade smores ice cream cake…
I was so excited to give it to him and thought I pulled off this big surprise …
And then about a hour later….he started to thank my family for the b-day presents….then told me to stand up (i had NO idea what was going on) and started to say how much he loved me….then all of a sudden he gets on his knee and pulls out the ring!!!
I was COMPLETELY shocked!!!
Post # 3
Did he like his smores cake? 🙂
Post # 4
Aw…YOU were his birthday present that he wanted most!!! CONGRATS!!!
Post # 5
Yay, congrats! yummy, smores cake! Maybe you should label it "engagement cake" and make it every year on your engagiversary!
Kinda like Self’s Engagement Chicken, lol
Post # 6
Congratulations!!!! The cake sounds yummy!
Post # 7
CONGRATS! I may be a bit emotional but I started tearing up. Engagment stories always make me a little verklept! 🙂
Post # 8
I must say I love the surprise proposal stories.
Post # 9
First…congratulations! Being surprised is cool.
Second… Holy cow! I just made a smores ice cream cake last weekend. Did you get your recipe from a magazine? I can’t remember.. Family Circle or Woman’s Day, maybe?
Post # 10
What a sweet story! Congrats!
I’d like the recipe as well … that sounds delicious!
Post # 11
Congratulations!!! What a great engagement story – shows that he can pull off a great surprise. All the best!
Post # 12
Congrats! Very cute that you each surprised eachother 🙂
Post # 13
Congratulations! Surprises are so fun, especially when they involved dessert and engagement 🙂
We got engaged this time last year. It was such a beautiful time to do it!
Post # 14
Congratulations and welcome to Weddingbee!! Like a previous poster said, you should definitely make it a tradition that you make that cake on your engagiversary!!
Post # 15
Congratulations! So much to celebrate!
Post # 16
Wow, what a terrific surprise — congratulations!!!!