Post # 1
Not to judge others for having larger rings, but for your own personal taste and finger size, etc. What is the largest rock you would be comfortable wearing?
I think a 3 carat would be my max on a size 5 finger.
Post # 3
@lilsweetie: Same for me.. 3 ct is about all I could take on my size 7 finger
Post # 4
My finger is a size 4.75. I don’t think there is a max for me. LOL. As long as it is tasteful. Like Beyonce’s 20 carat stunner and not Kim Kardashian’s hot mess.
Post # 5
Wow, much smaller.
It would be what I am wearing because it’s the perfect size for me (sometimes it seems a little large for me, but mostly I think it’s perfect). It is a normal size. I don’t mention my exact carat size bc I mentioned everything else about my diamond already on here, but let’s just say it’s less than half that size and I certainly don’t want bigger!! I am not a fan of honkers.
Post # 6
3-3.5 carat most likely on my 4.5 finger. Though, I’d be interested to try something on even larger. It really depends on cut and setting how good bigger stones look.
Post # 7
My max would be 1.5 carat center stone.
Anything more is “trying to show off” or “overkill”.
Post # 8
Personally, for an engagement ring I wear every day, I wouldn’t want more than 1 carat. I have small fingers and am easily irritated by big jewellery hitting on things etc. in daily life. However, I love the look of larger rings on others and would happily have a RHR up to 3 carats to wear occassionally if I could get that lucky!
Post # 9
My finger is a size 4. For a white diamond or clear/white stone I think 1 carat is my perfect size.
For a colored gemstone or black diamond I think 2.5 carats would be the largest I’d want.
I’ve just asked DH for a black diamond ring in the 2-2.5 carat range, so I hope it doesn’t end up looking too huge!
Post # 10
I’d say 2 carats for me. But mostly because I love halos and would stick with a halo.
Post # 11
- Wedding: October 2014 - Vegas baby!
I think 2 carats in a single stone would be my max. I’m not a blingy person. I live in hoodies and yoga pants ahaha. The ring I have now (temporary) is a 1 carat center with a halo. My forever ring will be a 7.5mm moissy (1.5 carat)
Post # 12
If I wanted something I thought was huge, 1ct max. My actual ring will be 0.4ct, which I think is perfect size for me.
Post # 13
I dont know if I can answer. I want to say 3 carats would be the max on my 4.75-5 finger but I guess it’s bc I can never imagine having a 20 carat ring.
Post # 14
my finger size is a 7 ( a UK N size) and my E ring is a 1 ct solitair, and personally any bigger looked too ‘in yer face’ for me.
Post # 16
My ring is 1 carat and I wouldn’t want anything much larger… I’d say 1.25 would be my absolute max.