(Closed) Whats your all time favorite Mascara

posted 9 years ago in Beauty
Post # 47
5889 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: May 2012

i always use estee lauder (waterproof)

Post # 48
792 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: June 2011

I feel like mascra is one of those things you can’t really go off what other people say, because as you can see some like one brand while another doesn’t like it, haha.

But anyway I love a few mascara’s. I like The falsies also by Maybelline. I don’t really use anything else right now, because I just haven’t bought anything else lately. I haven’t ever tried the waterproof version yet, but I want to try it to see if it’s actually waterproof, haha, but I actaully have found that the non waterproof version is a little waterproof also at least for me I can tear up and have a little bit of tears fall and dab my eyes dry and nothing is smudged or anything for me, so I like that, haha.

I also have an Avon brand, I think it is the wash-off waterproof mascara, I don’t know how well it works if you cry, because I haven’t cried in it yet, hahaha, but it does fine in genreal so far. A lot of people complain it’s hard to get off, but I have had no problems with that.

I also like the Cover Girl Lash Blast, but I ran out and just never went and got more, I don’t know what the waterproof version is like though.

I also use to have this other kind in like a neon green tube it was by maybelline. I think Maybelline define a lash, but I loved that stuff until I tried Lash Blast and then I just never went back to that, but it’s still good. I know they make a Maybelline define a lash volume in a purple tube but never tried that.

I also agree that I do not like that pink and green tube by maybelline, it just applies to thin for me. I feel like if I want to achieve the look I want I need to put so many coats of that stuff.I also don’t like Maybelline’s stiletto mascara, but my mom loves that stuff! I also don’t like Maybelline’s pulse perfection vibrating mascara, that stuff just didn’t do it for me- gave me length but didn’t hold curl well for me.

Haha, but yea those are mine, but like I said it’s different for everyone. My mom swears by Maybelline’s Stiletto mascra, but I hate the stuff. I also have friends who like the pink and green tube mascra, and so on. So everyone is different.

I think I have heavy eyelashes, but they don’t have a lot of curl, so I need something that will hold curl and give volume and a little bit of length.

Post # 49
10846 posts
Sugar Beekeeper
  • Wedding: September 2010

So I just bought Physician’s Formual Organic Mascara on a lark. It had a coupon on the box for a refund if you send the receipt so you get to try it for free, so I thought what the hey. I LOVE IT. I’m pretty sure it’s the best mascara I’ve ever tried and I’m pretty picky. It gives me length and doesn’t stick or clump at all, and it hasn’t smudged or flaked or budged on me yet! It’s easy to get off with make up remover at the end of the day. The only thing is that it’s not waterproof although I haven’t cried with it on yet, so I can’t report how bad the racoon effect is just yet 😉 Seriously though, if you see it, buy it, I’m THRILLED with it.

Post # 50
1184 posts
Bumble bee
  • Wedding: August 2011

go to sephora tomorrow and buy fiberwig mascara (or blinc mascara – different brand but exact same concept). i don’t ever splurge on make-up, except for this one product. it is so, so worth it.

Post # 51
270 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: June 2011

Dior’s DiorShow and Benefit’s Bad Gal Lash.  They both have the really fat brush, which I love.

Post # 52
482 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: August 2011

max factor false lash- fantastique!

Post # 53
99 posts
Worker bee
  • Wedding: May 2013

I love Blinc mascara for a casual, everyday eye. The tubing aspect is kind of neat, especially if you hate scrubbing your eyes to get mascara off. Bonus: no raccoon eyes, and it lasts through tears/watery eyes.

For good buildable coverage I really love Clinique’s mascara that comes in the dark green sparkly tube (sorry I forget the name!). I always get asked if I’m wearing falsies when I put on 3 layers of that stuff! The best part is it’s not much more expensive than drugstore stuff, but feels kind of special 🙂

I’ve tried Shu Uemura’s basic mascara, Imju Fiberwig, Estee Lauder, and Lancome which were all okay, but nothing super special for the price. I never saw the “wow” in that Dior mascara everyone raves about…

I do like a lot of the drugstore mascaras from L’Oreal and Maybelline (just not the green & pink one!!!). I’ve not had good luck with any of the mascaras from Revlon, though.

Sheesh…this helped me realize how much of a make-up junkie I am!!

Post # 54
126 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: May 2011

Blinc’s “Kiss Me” mascara for me too!  I HATE racoon eyes.  I find that I can build the intensitiy with layers.  So for everyday a put on nine strokes and double that for evening.

Post # 55
994 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: September 2011

I love Dior mascaras, I have three (extase, iconic & blackout). I also love Loreal Voluminous.



Post # 56
5109 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: November 2011

Im still in love with the maybeilline great lash.. the pink and green stuff. I have used it for years and whenever I try to switch it up I always end up going back to that. 

Post # 57
642 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: July 2011

Benefit’s Bad Gal Lash, and when I am counting my pennies (like now because of this wedding!) I use Covergirl’s Lashblast in the orange tube.  It’s the closest I’ve found to Bad Gal and cost’s about 1/3 of the price.

The topic ‘Whats your all time favorite Mascara’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors