(Closed) What’s your favorite drugstore eyeliner?

posted 7 years ago in Beauty
Post # 3
115 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: May 2012

I LOVE the Milani pencil liner…I forget the exact name of it. But it’s great. 

Post # 4
2792 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: September 2012

I love Maybelline Stiletto and L’Oreal Lineur Intense.

Post # 5
3671 posts
Sugar bee
  • Wedding: March 2011

My favorite is the Rimmel Exaggerate eyeliner.  I love that it comes in bold colors as well as black and brown.  It also stays on really well too. 

Post # 6
16191 posts
Honey Beekeeper

I use Revlon’s ColorStay because I have oily skin and sometimes have issues with my eyeliner smudging at the crease of my eyelid. It goes on smoothly and stays put! It’s just a little tough to wash off at the end of the day.

Post # 7
41 posts

I love Cover Girl perfect blend eyeliner.  It goes on super easy and it has a nice point that doesn’t get too thick

Post # 9
4366 posts
Honey bee
  • Wedding: September 2018

MAC for pencil/kohl.  Body Shop for liquid, it doesn’t clump.

ETA Just realised you asked for drugstore, in which case I’d say Rimmel for pencil/kohl and BarryM for liquid.  But I know that BarryM is a british brand, so’s Rimmel but I’m not sure if you have it in the states or not.

Post # 10
518 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: November 2012

I’m overly passionate about my L’real HIP cream eyeliner.  Its in a little pot and comes with an angle brush for application.  I’m a huge makeup person, but the pencil liners have never worked for me…to thick of a line, not smooth enough, not enough color, etc.  I got to the point where I was using an angle eye liner brush with the pencil eyeliner.  When this product came out I fell in love with it and I have in it every color.  One pot will probably last for years as I’ve never bought a 2nd pot of even black, which I wear most days.  Its definitely worth a try!

Post # 11
441 posts
Helper bee
  • Wedding: September 2014

I have been on a hunt to try and find a eyeliner that doesnt make my eyes swell (I looked like I had bug eyes today!) Anyways, tonight I bough Almay Hypoallergenic eyeliner so I am HOPING this will be my favorite!

Post # 12
6394 posts
Bee Keeper
  • Wedding: September 2011

Hey! I use the Sephora eyeliner. If I wear it with eye primer, it doesn’t smudge (which is really, really impressive because I have somewhat oily skin and my eyeliner always smudges). I would definitely give it a try if I were you!

Post # 13
5667 posts
Bee Keeper

Skip the drugstore brands and go with Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide on Pencil. Seriously the best eyeliner ever and at $18 it’s not unreasonable.

Post # 14
111 posts
Blushing bee
  • Wedding: December 2012

NYX Glide on pencil!  Comes in a ton of great shades, easy to use, almost exactly like the Urban Decay!

Post # 15
701 posts
Busy bee
  • Wedding: August 2012

@Aure: agreed- urban decay’s is the best. You could also get the pack that has smaller pencils in all the different colors so you can make more looks. It’s TOTALLY worth the extra cost

Post # 16
331 posts
Helper bee

@mandb122:  I LOVE this kind!! I use the brown and they have a gorgeous midnight blue that’s semi-sparkly in the right lighting. I like the creaminess of it… the NYX pencil liner kind do nothing for me and I’m horrible at liquid liner.

The topic ‘What’s your favorite drugstore eyeliner?’ is closed to new replies.

Find Amazing Vendors