Post # 1
We’re still looking to book our honeymoon but wondering where YOU would go! If you have been to any of these places let me know your opinion! We are looking to stay at an All Inclusive resort and adults/couples only if possible (but not possible in all locations).
Post # 3
I’d go to St. Lucia personally although none of those options seem bad!
Post # 4
@Mrs.KMM: Agreed. Since neither Fiance and I can take more than a week off after the wedding, we will probably head to St. Lucia as well since Fiance loves it there.
Post # 5
St Lucia is by far the most beautiful island.
Aruba is mostly desert, you don’t get that beautiful lush greenery like St Lucia.
The Bahamas has beautiful blue water but the islands aren’t anything too special, there are neat things to see and do but again you lack that something special that St Lucia has.
Post # 6
i’ve been to aruba and it is phenomenal. But I voted for St. Lucia becuase I wantt to go there!
Post # 7
I’ve heard so many great things about St. Lucia and the virgin islands! I would so go there!
Post # 8
St. Lucia looks amazing but then again all three options you have listed would be great. I’ve never been to any of them so I really have no advice for ya.
Post # 9
I voted for the Bahamas. I was going to vote for st.Lucia but its a long trip!
Post # 10
Aruba is flat and desert. I like islands that have mountains and lush greenery
Post # 11
I voted Aruba. I have been to the other two places.
Post # 12
- Wedding: March 2012 - Pelican Grand Beach Resort
If you can go to St. Lucia, go there. It’s so expensive though.
My BFF was recently in Aruba and she was really disappointed. She expected something really special but she thought it was the most boring of all the Caribbean islands she’s been to.
The Bahamas are lovely. I’m from Florida, though, so to me, the Bahamas is where you go when you must get away but can’t afford something expensive so you just take a prop plane over for the weekend. But, from the perspective of NY, I’d consider the Bahamas amazing. There’s a lot to do and a lot to see, especially if you will island hop some. I’d go there if St. Lucia is too expensive in the end.
Post # 13
I would love to go to the Bahamas 🙂
Post # 14
I have never been to any, but I asked my Uncle who has a few years ago where he liked the best and he said hands down Aruba.
Post # 15
I’d say St. Lucia first and then Bahamas as a second choice. I’ve been to the Bahamas and I hear that St. Lucia is nicer. I have zero interest in Aruba.