Post # 1
I’m considering getting rid of one of my rings (as I have two and don’t see the need for both) but I cannot decide which one I would rather keep.
both erings are pictured with just my wedding band (plain gold band) and my ring stack if I feel like switching it up (wedding band and twisted band)
round is 1.25 carat and oval is 2 carat. My finger size is 5.5 so please help on which one looks best and which one you would vote to keep.
Post # 2
I would keep the oval because it’s bigger
Post # 3
It depends if you like more finger coverage keep the oval. If you like less finger coverage keep the round. Both are beautiful. Me perfect I’d keep the oval.
Post # 4
You have posted something similar before, and you’re probably going to get the same answers, Bee. That last thread was super active. If you’re still on the fence, return them both and find something you love more.
Post # 5
Unless you need the money why not keep both? They both look pretty on you. That said i would likely opt for the oval myself. Just because i don’t have one myself and it’s very pretty 🙂
Post # 6
I really love the oval on you.
Post # 7
- Wedding: February 2005 - Shreveport, LA
I voted oval on your first thread and my vote is still oval! It’s stunning on you!
Post # 8
Because you will likely lose a ton of money on whichever one you sell, I would keep both and have one of the stones made into a pendant.
Post # 9
Both of them are gorgeous, but I agree with others, keep the oval. More finger coverage plus it’s a timeless and classic solitaire.
Post # 10
I prefer the oval. It gives better finger coverage.
Post # 11
The oval is more beautiful IMO
Post # 12
If they’re diamonds, I’d just keep them both and wait to repurpose one into somthing I really like later on since the resale value is so bad.
If they’re not, I like the oval better on you and would ger rid of the round.
Post # 13
Oval is more on trend but I would choose round for you.
I personally love ovals though.
Post # 14
Normally I would pick the bigger stone, as I LOVE big diamonds. But I think the round looks much prettier & is more flattering on your hand.
Granted, I’m not a fan of ovals.