Post # 1
Hi guys, I need help choosing my engagement ring. One is 1 carat the other is 2 carats but do you think it’s too big for my finger? Should I go with the carat instead?
Read more: http://boards.weddingbee.com/topic/which-ring-22/#ixzz3bfWnwaPs
Post # 2
The top one look much better and classier imo. The bottom just looks like a messy cluster, which I’m not a fan of.
Post # 3
I’m typically a big bling lover, it depends on what your comfortable with. Diamond shrinkage syndrome is real, it may feel big at first but after you get use to wearing it you may be glad you went with the bigger ring. However I think the bigger one looks more like a cluster than a 3 stone halo which I’m not a fan of. So I voted for 1 carat
Post # 4
In that style of ring I actually prefer the 1 carat!
Post # 5
Ditto the PP on picking the 1ct one. The 3 stone design is clearer with the 1ct and harder to discern with the 2ct.
Post # 6
I like the top one better. It looks more clean and sleek compared to the second one.
Post # 7
I think the picture with the 2 carat isn’t clear and unfortunately it’s the only photo I have. I am leaning towards the 1 carat. Thanks for the feedback guys!!
Post # 9
most def the one carat is way better. I never thought I would Say this about diamonds, but the two carat looks blah. It also overwhelms your finger.
Post # 11
It looks very much like a ring they used to have when I worked at Kay Jewelers. If it’s the ring I remember it constantly had issues with the pave diamonds falling out. I wouldn’t purchase it if it were me. A lot of customers grew frustrated with the way it was made. Just a thought. Good luck!
Post # 12
- Wedding: November 2009 - New York, NY
The 1 carat looks classier and more balanced on your hand.
Post # 13
The 1 carat looks balanced and elegant. The 2 carat is way too overwhelming. What’s your finger size? About a 4.5 maybe? Because that would explain why the 2 carat looks so massive.
Post # 14
I would have thought I’d have said ‘go for the big one’ but actually the first one is much more stylish and you can see the nice diamond clearly. So in this case I’d vote for no 1.
Post # 15
I love the first one best:)