Post # 1
All things being equal, which of these two do you like better? What are the pluses and minuses of the size/design/shapes? Since I won’t be wearing a separate ring whatever I choose will be both my engagement ring and wedding band.
The first one is significantly wider and thus more “wow” at a distance. I have very large hands, and according to both the woman in the store and my fiance, this one is more proportionate. However, it’s major bling and very showy!
The second one is simply gorgeous in real life. The stones sparkle and are just lovely. Also, my fiance prefers to see larger stones rather than a lot of smaller stones such as ring 1. However, it’s less proportionate to my hand and less showy. It’s more for “up close.” Also, I’m wondering if the style is more “ordinary”?
Post # 3
They are both GORGEOUS and you are one lucky little bee ! Personally, I would probably decide on number 2.
Post # 5
I love #1 – I have larger hands and long fingers too and think that would just be beautiful on.
Post # 6
I would have to agree on number 2
Post # 7
WOW! crazy blingy rings! Both are beautiful. Maybe it would help to see your e-ring to get an idea of how they’d all look together.
If you’re looking for something “showy” and really dramatic I’d say the 1st one.
Post # 10
I think they’re both great! However, I’d go with the 1st one. Reasons being- I’d want something that ‘fits’ my finger and I have no problems with having lots of bling… as long as we didn’t go into major debt to do it! Plus, its much more unique than the 2nd choice. Did you take pictures of the rings on your hand? So you could look at them and think it through? Regardless, take your time making your decision, ya wanna make sure its the right pick since it will be on your finger forever 🙂
Post # 11
I have very short fingers so # 2 would be my choice. But i like number 1 better.
Post # 12
I like #1 based on your descriptions of your hand. That said, you’ll look at this ring every day for the rest of your life; I think that ESPECIALLY with rings, you need to follow your heart 🙂
Post # 13
I like ring #2 personally. I don’t like big, blingly rings.
Post # 14
For everyday I would prefer #2. Number 1 would be a special occasion ring for me, almost like costume jewelry. They are both gorgeous though.
Post # 15
Maybe you could add a poll. I like #2 better.
Post # 16
If you were going to wear this along with an engagement ring I would pick #2 but since this is going to act as both your wedding band and your engagement ring I would say go with #1. It’s will stand along much better. But really you can’t make a bad choice, they are both beautiful.