Post # 17
Member594 posts
Busy bee
- Mdmc
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: July 1993
the solitare is my vote. You get simple elegance now and you. can halo it in the future if you want
- CategoriesEvents
poll: Which one should I get?
Get the simple one. Save money. : (65 votes)
67 %
Get the oval halo. it's really pretty and good for the price. : (26 votes)
27 %
Don't get the halo it's too expensive. : (2 votes)
2 %
Don't get the simple one everyone has it. : (4 votes)
4 %
MemberPost # 18
Member2049 posts
Buzzing bee
- heathuhhhhweeee
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: May 2013
I’d continue to shop around. However if that isn’t an option, go with the one you love!
Post # 19
Member6506 posts
Bee Keeper
- echomomm
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: February 1997
Blue Nile prices ovals that are smaller than yours (same specs) at around $6K, setting not included, so if the stone is GIA certified and you prefer the oval, it is at a good price.
Post # 20
Member1258 posts
Bumble bee
- megan331979
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: May 2014
I picked the simple one because it’s beautiful!!! I love solitaires 🙂
good luck picking…let us know what one you go with!
Post # 21
Member1935 posts
Buzzing bee
- BlondeBee
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: February 2014
@Mrs_BunInTheOven: without seeing them in person, I’m clearly going to go for the oval halo (check out my avatar.) However, if you haven’t looked at it up close, be careful – ovals can show inclusions easily. It took us about 3 months to find one we liked. If the inclusions are hidden or under the prongs, go for it!
Post # 22
Member878 posts
Busy bee
- foz
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: June 2015
@Mrs_BunInTheOven: Based on looks, definitely the solitaire! Much more classic (coming from someone with a micropave halo and shank), although I’d be concerned about the I clarity. Maybe it’s just the picture, but the diamonds in the pave of the oval ring look…meh… Do you have any other pictures?
Post # 23
Member2570 posts
Sugar bee
- SunflowerGarden
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: November 2012
I like the oval, but I am a halo girl so I’m certainly bias. Both are lovely though and I don’t think you could go wrong with those options! 🙂
Post # 24
Member6354 posts
Bee Keeper
- joya_aspera
- 6 years ago
I’d suggest a better quality solitaire.
Post # 25
Member78 posts
Worker bee
- BellieBee
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: July 2014
If you are anything like me, and compromise on the smaller ring that you don’t love as much, you will always wish you had that oval halo.
Post # 26
Member479 posts
Helper bee
- Mrs_BunInTheOven
- 6 years ago
- Wedding: January 2014 - Monte Carlo inn
Thanks for all the comments ladies! I really apreciate all the responses!! I know I love the simple solitaire but honestly when I saw the 2 rings again today, I just knew I found a winner 🙂 even my fiancé smiled when I tried it on 🙂 I finally made my decision today and we went to get the one I really really really love……*drum roll*…..
…The gorgeous oval halo 🙂
Post # 27
Member163 posts
Blushing bee
- futurejhart
- 6 years ago
I personally much prefer the simple one but if you’re not going to be thrilled with it then you will never like it
The topic ‘Which ring should I get?’ is closed to new replies.