- Mdmc
- 7 years ago
- Wedding: July 1993
the solitare is my vote. You get simple elegance now and you. can halo it in the future if you want
the solitare is my vote. You get simple elegance now and you. can halo it in the future if you want
I’d continue to shop around. However if that isn’t an option, go with the one you love!
Blue Nile prices ovals that are smaller than yours (same specs) at around $6K, setting not included, so if the stone is GIA certified and you prefer the oval, it is at a good price.
I picked the simple one because it’s beautiful!!! I love solitaires ๐
good luck picking…let us know what one you go with!
@Mrs_BunInTheOven: without seeing them in person, I’m clearly going to go for the oval halo (check out my avatar.) However, if you haven’t looked at it up close, be careful – ovals can show inclusions easily. It took us about 3 months to find one we liked. If the inclusions are hidden or under the prongs, go for it!
@Mrs_BunInTheOven: Based on looks, definitely the solitaire! Much more classic (coming from someone with a micropave halo and shank), although I’d be concerned about the I clarity. Maybe it’s just the picture, but the diamonds in the pave of the oval ring look…meh… Do you have any other pictures?
I like the oval, but I am a halo girl so I’m certainly bias. Both are lovely though and I don’t think you could go wrong with those options! ๐
I’d suggest a better quality solitaire.
If you are anything like me, and compromise on the smaller ring that you don’t love as much, you will always wish you had that oval halo.
Thanks for all the comments ladies! I really apreciate all the responses!! I know I love the simple solitaire but honestly when I saw the 2 rings again today, I just knew I found a winner ๐ even my fiancé smiled when I tried it on ๐ I finally made my decision today and we went to get the one I really really really love……*drum roll*…..
…The gorgeous oval halo ๐
I personally much prefer the simple one but if you’re not going to be thrilled with it then you will never like it
The topic ‘Which ring should I get?’ is closed to new replies.