(Closed) Which ring should I get?

• Mdmc
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: July 1993

the solitare is my vote. You get simple elegance now and you. can halo it in the future if you want

• colormeheather
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: October 2018

I’d continue to shop around.  However if that isn’t an option, go with the one you love!

• echomomm
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: February 1997

Blue Nile prices ovals that are smaller than yours (same specs) at around $6K, setting not included, so if the stone is GIA certified and you prefer the oval, it is at a good price. 

• megan331979
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: May 2014

I picked the simple one because it’s beautiful!!! I love solitaires 🙂

good luck picking…let us know what one you go with!

• BlondeBee
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: February 2014

@Mrs_BunInTheOven:  without seeing them in person, I’m clearly going to go for the oval halo (check out my avatar.) However, if you haven’t looked at it up close, be careful – ovals can show inclusions easily. It took us about 3 months to find one we liked. If the inclusions are hidden or under the prongs, go for it!

• foz
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: June 2015

@Mrs_BunInTheOven:  Based on looks, definitely the solitaire! Much more classic (coming from someone with a micropave halo and shank), although I’d be concerned about the I clarity. Maybe it’s just the picture, but the diamonds in the pave of the oval ring look…meh… Do you have any other pictures?

• SunflowerGarden
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: November 2012

I like the oval, but I am a halo girl so I’m certainly bias. Both are lovely though and I don’t think you could go wrong with those options! 🙂

• joya_aspera
• 7 years ago

I’d suggest a better quality solitaire.

• BellieBee
• 7 years ago

• Wedding: July 2014

If you are anything like me, and compromise on the smaller ring that you don’t love as much, you will always wish you had that oval halo. 

• futurejhart
• 7 years ago

I personally much prefer the simple one but if you’re not going to be thrilled with it then you will never like it