Post # 1
I bought the plain one months ago because it fitted well with my ring and I always assumed I’d get a plain one. At the time I tried on some with diamonds in but they all looked odd as the diamonds were too big or the shape was wrong so I bought the plain one and thought nothing more of it. It is now too late to return the plain one for anything other than possibly some store credit if I’m lucky. But I recently found this sparkly one that I really like but I’m just not sure what too do as the sparkly one will take more care and cleaning and is quite ‘bling’ for me as I never wear jewelery… Help! Which is better?!
Post # 2
I love both but I think I like the diamond one a bit more!
Post # 3
I prefer the plain one i think the diamond one distracts slightly from your engagement ring which is gorgeous!
Post # 4
I like them both. Since the diamonds in the band are prong set there shouldn’t be much maintenance and would be easy to clean. So it really just depends on if you want a simple or blingy look. I don’t think you can go wrong either way, they both look great.
Post # 5
cpick: LOVE the diamond band!
Post # 6
Plain one. Your ring is very pretty and it stands out more.
Post # 7
Plain. The diamond one looks like it doesn’t quite fit with the ering.
Post # 8
If you plan on wearing your wedding band alone sometimes then the plain band would be the best option since the diamond band is curved and wouldn’t look good by itself. You could always keep the plain band for now and get the diamond band for an anniversary or a milestone. That way you would still have the plain one for times you can’t wear your ering.
Post # 9
cpick: I really like the plain band! It looks so elegant.
Post # 10
Both have the plane as wedding band on one side of e.ring and dia set at et ring on other side
Post # 11
- Wedding: April 2015 - Family Farm
cpick: plain. It’s perfect. The diamond is pretty but it’s not quite as good a fit as the plain one.
Post # 12
- Wedding: April 2007 - City, State
I really like the plain one with your rings. It makes your ring stand out!
Post # 13
I like the plain one so much better!
Let’s number the diamonds in the diamond band 1 through 5 from left to right. Can you see how the bezel on the top and bottom of diamonds 4 and 5 are horizontal with respect to the band? The bezel for diamond 2 is WAY off, with diamond 3 not far behind. The bottom of diamond 1 doesn’t match its top.
I’m sorry to nit pick, but I don’t think the diamond band was made with quality in mind. If you are looking for some bling, I think you could do much better.
Post # 14
Normally curved bands aren’t my favorite, but I really think that diamond curved band looks GREAT with your e-ring! It’s the perfect match and that’s what I would go with. 🙂
Post # 15
cpick: The diamond band looks beautiful, but I do feel it pulls aways from the ering a bit. I’m a big fan of plain bands though, obviously since I have one.