Post # 1
Tradition aside….would you rather eat a piece of cake, a piece pie, or ice cream. In order to help you make your choice….The cake would have buttercream frosting. The pie would be homemade with homegrown fruit (and probably a pumpkin pie or two). And the ice cream would simply be served from an old fashioned icecream cart. Ice cream sandwiches, strawberry shortcake, etc.
My fiancee doesnt like cake. And doesnt really care if we have cake at our wedding at all. Surprisingly….it doesnt make a huge difference to me. But we definitely would need an alternative dessert. Our wedding is a fall/rustic wedding in September…so i think the pies or ice cream cart would serve its purpose…im just wondering what the guests would prefer eating?! Thanks for any input/help!
Post # 3
Pie! All the way! Especially for a fall wedding. yummmm
Post # 4
We had friends do a gelato bar at their wedding because they didn’t like cake. It was awesome!
I chose ice cream only because I’m not really a pie person.
Post # 5
I think an ice cream bar would be fabulous! I voted for cake because I love cake! DH didn’t want cake – so we opted for an ice cream cake (his fav).
What I missed out on (that I didn’t realize I’d be sad about after the fact) was us cutting a beautiful tiered cake. We got a cake cutting picture, but it wasn’t what I wished I had in my head (or get a touch sad about when I look at photos). And, we never went cake tasting!
I’ve decided that if we reach a big milestone anniversary (like 25 or something) I’m going to get my ginormous, tiered cake! 🙂
Post # 5
Gah, I voted for pie before I saw the pie/icecream option! Although I would prefer just a scoop of icecream with that awesome sounding pie.
Also… I’m normally a cake person, but.. come on… homemade pie!
Post # 6
There have been several brides who did a pie table – I would love that!
Post # 8
We’re doing a dessert table, so I’m probably biased, but I voted pie/ice cream. I would be stoked about an ice cream bar at a wedding. It just seems like so much fun, and I find that people don’t usually enjoy wedding cake, anyway.
Post # 10
Well, unless it’s a super fancy flavor of ice cream like blue moon, I personally would prefer cake. But I definitely wouldn’t complain about pumpkin pie or ice cream either 🙂
Post # 11
I vote cake because I love cake and am not a big pie person.
Post # 11
I looooove pie. Definitely pie for me!
Post # 14
- Wedding: May 2012 - The Chapel of the Sir Christopher Wren Building, 2007 Legacy Hall
I voted for pie. (YUM.) But I think go with either pie or the ice cream. I’m not really a cake person either so I understand the want to do something different.