Post # 1
My fiancé did a surprise proposal and i never had any input on the ring he picked out. He got me a solitaire but from the start I feltl that the design isn’t really me, as I like a more blingy look, and have always liked the halo style. I have been wearing my ring proudly nonetheless, but am thinking of resetting the ring (same diamond, different setting) into a halo style which I prefer. I hope to do the reset before the wedding as I want to be married in it. Don’t intend to upgrade/ change it in the future after the resetting.
I’m however concerned that people I see often (mainly co workers) will judge me for changing the Setting / seeing this as an upgrade of my ring.I’m think people will notice the change as its quite a big difference from solitaire to halo in my opinion. Im concerned of being seen as ungrateful/ fussy/ materialistic especially at work. at the same time, I just want a ring design I really like as I didn’t get to pick it out when he proposed As a surprise. What are your thoughts ladies?
Also, what should I say if people ask in order not to be judged too harshly?
Post # 2
Congrats on the engagement.
Have you discussed the change in ring settings with your FI? If he is on board with the setting change, nobody else’s opinions matter. If you coworkers want to judge you, that’s on them. That is out of your control. Be happy with your upgraded ring, and move on. And if someone asks you, you tell them the truth. “I wanted a different setting.”
Post # 3
Chicpeas: I wouldn’t worry so much about the opinion of others but if you are concerned why not get a wrap for your wedding band – that way you’ll have the blingy look after you’re married?
Post # 4
Chicpeas: If you’re concerned about judgemental people (which, I don’t blame you), why not get a halo wrap wedding band? That way you’re still ‘upgrading’ your ring, but at the same time getting the ring you want?
Honestly – I think your attitude is fine. It’s going to sit on your finger the rest of your life – why should you be forced to stay with something that isn’t quite you? What does your Fiance think about resetting it? I would just ignore anyone with a negative opinion at work, and get what you and your Fiance feel comfortable getting.
Post # 5
If your Fiance doesn’t mind you changing the setting, then I say who cares what everyone else thinks. Just say you and your Fiance changed it to fit more your style.
I have a .10 carat diamond silver ring and I’m upgrading to a 1920s platinum, 1.01 carat diamond ring after 4 months of marriage. Lol
Post # 6
I voted yes because you will always be judged for anything you do in life that could be conceived as rude/selfish or whatever no matter how true your intentions are.
Will I judge you? No. Does it matter if I judge you? It really shouldn’t. You are going to wear this ring for the rest of your life. It should be something you’re happy with!! Do what’s best for you and your Fiance and don’t let the haters drag you down!
(After reading this through, it sounds harsh but my intentions for this post was to be honest and straightforward!)
Post # 7
Congratulations on your engagement! And who cares what other people think! I’ve changed my engagement ring 4 times in 2 years and yeah I’m sure some people think I’m superficial and a bit crazy lol but I love diamonds and love changing it up, as my style frequently changes. My husband says he’s happy if I’m happy and doesn’t mind a bit. So do what makes you happy and if anyone has anything negative to say about it just remember that most likely they are jealous.
Post # 8
- Wedding: November 2009 - New York, NY
Other people’s opinions should be irrelevant. If you and your SO are in agreement, that’s all that matters.
Post # 9
Congrats on the engagement and upcoming wedding!
My best friend didn’t necessarily upgrate TO a halo, but she changed her halo because she was very OCD about it and concerned because her ring is a princess center stone with a round/cushion halo. She changed it to a square halo to match the stone and she’s so much happier. I don’t even remember her mentioning how her husband felt about it or how she thought other people might feel, probably because it doesn’t matter!! (Husband matters, but you’re the one who has to wear it the rest of your life!) If he’s ok with it to, then go for it and eff everyone else!!
Post # 10
If your Fiance is onboard, then all you need to tell your coworkers (if they would ever be so incredibly rude as to ask) is that he proposed with a solitaire so that you could later choose the setting of your choice. Say you two planned it that way. In the end, as long as you and Fiance are happy, it is no one else’s business.
Post # 11
- Wedding: October 2014 - Cape May
You don’t owe any one an explanation. It’s between you and your FI when you upgrade or change a setting. FWIW I also reset my ring before our upcoming wedding. I felt it most important to be married with the ring I plan on keeping. I didn’t want to have a whole new ring after the wedding. Plus this way you can pick the wedding band to match the new setting.
Post # 12
Yes you will probably be judged by some, but it’s whether you care and take that to heart that matters. For me, the idea of an upgrade because someone ‘never got to choose my own ring’, doesn’t sit well. But each to their own and what others do doesn’t impact my life so what people think shouldn’t impact yours. What matters is if you and fi are both happy for the change and ok for some people to see you as materialistic (I’m not saying you are, just that that will be the impression by some people) as the sentimental value Is kinda gone.
Post # 13
Opinions are like you know what. Everyone has one. Some of those opinions may be that they liked the look of your original solitaire and that it’s silly that you felt the need to add the halo. Some may love the bling of the new setting. Most people are not going to care or even notice. All that really counts is how you and Fiance feel.
If they are that nosy, are your colleagues really so familiar with your engagement story that they know why you started out with a solitaire? For all they know this setting was an heirloom or a place holder and you and Fiance were waiting for a custom setting to be made.
You have nothing to defend or justify. If someone does ask I’d have no problem just saying the setting was in the works from the start. Which it was, in your mind.
Post # 14
How does your fiance sincerely feel about this? If he’s fine with it, then go ahead and do it. Who cares what people think. My fiance chose my ring and I know it would hurt his feelings if I went and changed it. While it may have not been the exact design I would have chosen, I think it’s beautiful and I love it because he chose it.
Post # 15
Artseas: weddingmaven: mazzoffee: Strawberryshmoo: echomomm: SoccerBee86: Robyn0214: Robyn0214: mrssloan2013: westgirl1208: OMGMrsW2B: MsGinkgo: gillykat824: newbeelove:
hi all thanks so much for the overwhelming comments (: appreciate each one of them!(:
Yes, i do agree everyone has an opinion, and i dont have to care what others think. I guess im just concerned in the context of work because there are implications of being judged, as you dont want any judgment to affect what your co-workers think of you and it may affect your career? Hmm.. or maybe i am just over thinking (: i even thought about not wearing my ring to work till im married so that i wont draw so much attention to my new ring and everyone will be just thinking”oh thats her wedding ring”..