(Closed) Would you have another baby if your children were against the idea?

posted 8 years ago in Parenting
  • poll: If my current child didn't want me to have another baby

    I would still have a baby

    I would not have a baby

    I would wait until they were ready

    I wouldn't wait-but try to help them through it

    This happened to me and everything worked out in the end

    This happened to me and everything got worse

  • Post # 32
    6261 posts
    Bee Keeper
    • Wedding: August 2013 - The Liberty House

    I think that your son at 5 doesn’t really know what is the best decision in this matter.  He is probably afraid that he won’t get as much of your fiance’s attention, but once the baby came you could show him that isn’t true

    Post # 33
    13905 posts
    Honey Beekeeper
    • Wedding: November 1999

    I would still have the child.  A five year old does not get dictate my family planning choices.  Of course they are an important consideration, but five year olds don’t exactly have the best grasp of the situation.

    When my younger brother was born, my pre-school teacher commented on how cute he was, and my response (as a 5 year old) was, “I’ll sell him to you, we don’t want him.”  I love my brother to death, and couldn’t imagine my life without him.  But if my parents opted not to have him because I liked being the baby of the family..my life and my family would be incomplete.

    Post # 34
    3941 posts
    Honey bee
    • Wedding: October 2011

    I apologize if this sounds rude, but he’s 5!  Of course his opinion is he doesn’t want another sibling, he probably doesn’t want to tie his shoes or go to bed at a certain time either!

    Live your life and have another child if you want to.  Your 5 year old (a couple years down the line) will be so thankful you vetoed his “decision”.  And he’ll be so happy to have that sibling the day that it arrives.

    Post # 35
    10361 posts
    Sugar Beekeeper
    • Wedding: September 2010

    5-year-olds don’t have the rationalization skills to choose whether their adult parent should procreate or not. It isn’t his body or his choice!

    Obviously, help him through the process, but I don’t really understand why you’re entertaining the idea of him having a say.

    Post # 37
    883 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: September 2012

    Uh, when I was 2 1/2 my brother was born, I had no say whatsover, and did everything in my power to try to make him go away…..then when I was 9 1/2 our sister was born, and trust me we would have preferred a puppy; however her birth made my brother and I closer, we now had a united front to try to make her go away…. 🙂

    We all survived, and if any of us needed a kidney, the repsonse would be, “which one, left or right”.  The running joke is  I was wanted, my brother was a surprise and my sister was a mistake.  And none of us needed years of therapy and we have made to our late forties through mid fifties. And my sister and I are closer than sisters should be, inspite of a 9 year age difference.

    Whether blended or not, most kids want mommy and daddy to theirselves and are not thrilled with any interlopers!



    Post # 38
    5789 posts
    Bee Keeper

    For a child so young, those fears are irrational, unless someone has been feeding it to him. They can’t understand a family dynamic, let alone verbalize about it. Being smart has nothing to do with it, but it is certainly understandable that whatever he’s saying is giving you pause and to reconsider. Most kids are afraid of the unknown and are even taught fear by what they hear. I’d be wondering where he’s actually getting all this from, to be honest. Is his bio-Dad evil enough to be planting these seeds of doubt in his head?

    All of your lives will be changing, so of course he’s feeling a bit unsure of where he will fit in. The best you can do is to reassure him repeatedly that nothing will REALLY change. Maybe that’s what he’s most afraid of,the changes, and not about not wanting a sibling at all. I get that, and that may never go away, and he may go through these same feelings if you decide to buy a new house and he has to adjust to a new school and neighborhood. Does that mean you wouldn’t consider moving because he might be upset about it? Probably not. You’ll do everything you can to make his transition into an easy one, won’t you?

    No one is saying that children aren’t people too, but they aren’t capable of making rational,informed decisions about life changing events either, and especially at five. You’re a good Mom to be weighing everything out, and hopefully people are giving you some food for thought.

    The topic ‘Would you have another baby if your children were against the idea?’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors