(Closed) Would you like this ring?

posted 8 years ago in Rings
  • poll: Would you like this ring?




  • Post # 48
    487 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: October 2013

    I like the idea of a claddaugh ring, but I’m not a huge fan of emeralds.  If I were given that with a different colored stone, I’d be all right with that.

    Post # 50
    441 posts
    Helper bee


    I hate the ring. Hate. The. Ring. 

    Unfortunately, when he asked your opinion it was probably the equivalent of us asking if these jeans make my butt look fat. An honest answer really isn’t wanted. The only exception would be if you were very dear friends with much trust between you. Perhaps your boyfriend can talk to him. 

    I hate to be snarky, I know it isn’t always the case, but getting engaged after 3 months increases the likelihood the engagement may not last. Upgrading this ring to a diamond with a more traditional setting could end up a big financial mistake for him. If she hates it she’ll tell him once their relationship has gelled and more trust has built. He can get her the ring of her dreams in the future . 

    Post # 51
    1230 posts
    Bumble bee
    • Wedding: October 2014

    Unless she’s shown you rings that she likes, you can’t really say anything cause you don’t know for sure imo

    Post # 52
    8467 posts
    Bumble Beekeeper
    • Wedding: July 2012

    Nope. I’d hate it. 

    Post # 53
    1258 posts
    Bumble bee
    • Wedding: May 2014

    Personally, I love claddagh rings and maybe he already knows that his girlfriend likes them.  If I was given a claddagh ring as an e-ring I would either want a diamond in the center or just plain yellow gold…I don’t really care for the emerald. Everyone’s taste is different, and I hope he knows what she likes…..I know some people hate claddagh rings, so…..you either like them or you don’t.

    Like others have mentioned…I wouldn’t say anything to him…maybe you could just ask him if he’s asked her before what she likes…see how he decided on that particular ring. 

    Congrats to him….I hope she loves it!


    Post # 54
    523 posts
    Busy bee
    • Wedding: June 2014

    I would laugh, and tell him to return it. Even the promise ring I had when I was like twelve was fancier than that. Not everyone needs fact or expensive, but I do.

    I would also run the eff away from anyone that tried to propose after three months, so he wouldn’t be getting anywhere with me.

    Post # 55
    302 posts
    Helper bee
    • Wedding: April 2017

    I thought claddagh rings were made for people of Irish heritage… If I am right, the green stone makes it look even more fit to an Irish theme. I could be wrong though. I hope she likes it.

    Post # 56
    5062 posts
    Bee Keeper
    • Wedding: April 2014

    I really like it & I love the green stone. 

    Post # 57
    2977 posts
    Sugar bee
    • Wedding: August 2011

    I would not like this as an engagement ring.

    Post # 58
    2267 posts
    Buzzing bee

    View original reply
    @SomedaymrsWDS:   Unfortunately, when he asked your opinion it was probably the equivalent of us asking if these jeans make my butt look fat. An honest answer really isn’t wanted.”


    I don’t particularly like the ring and TBH; I would be more concerned about the length of their relationship and her reaction to his proposal, then the ring.

    Post # 59
    1284 posts
    Bumble bee
    • Wedding: September 2014

    One of my friends wants one for her engagement ring, and another one of my friends already has one and just wants to switch it to the other hand!  Until they told me that I NEVER would have guessed!  It’s hard to say what people would like.

    Post # 60
    9947 posts
    Buzzing Beekeeper
    • Wedding: December 2012

    To @spiffanee: It is a Claddagh Ring… which is an Irish Ring that has a long tradition when it comes to representing deep emotions… FRIENDSHIP (Hands) – LOVE (Heart) – and LOYALTY (Crown)

    Wikipedia – Claddagh Ring = http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claddagh_ring

    Depending on how it is worn on one’s hand signifies the Wearer’s status:

    • RH Point to the Fingertips = Available
    • RH Point to the Wrist = Taken
    • LH Point to the Fingertips = Engaged
    • LH Point to the Wrist = Married

    Over the years, I’ve know people who have worn them to represent any / all of the above.

    And I certainly have seen them used as everything from a Ring of Friendship (from a same sex friend) thru to a Promise Ring, ERing or WBand.

    Not to everyone’s taste perhaps for an ERing or WBand… but ALL that truly matters here is what the Girl getting it will think and whether she will appreciate / LOVE The Ring as an ERing.  Nothing else truly matters.

    Hope this helps,


    Post # 61
    9947 posts
    Buzzing Beekeeper
    • Wedding: December 2012


    I VOTED – YES I like this ring

    Because I do.  I like the look, I like the history, I like the sentiment.

    BUT after just 3 months of Dating, and it being Long Distance, I would be hopeful that the symbolism of the ring would be more “Promise” than Engagement in this particular situation

    (And for the record, there is nothing wrong with a Promise Ring no matters one’s age… PRings get a bad wrap… BUT I bet a lot of Ladies on the Waiting Boards would be happy with one if they knew it meant an Engagement Ring was being saved up for and in the works to come shortly.  Saying YES I want to marry you in the future with a Ring… doesn’t have to be an ERing)


    The topic ‘Would you like this ring?’ is closed to new replies.

    Find Amazing Vendors